I'm not gonna lie, 2 weeks is probably too long for a day. (People seem to often get disinterested) Any thoughts about shortening this to 1 week? Another alternative is just make first day 1 week and every day after could be 2 weeks if that's what the players want.
12/15/2016 02:47:29
I already pointed out that I didn't account for third party kills. I agree there will be people with night kill powers other than the mafia this game.
I can run the numbers with 5 mafia / assuming third party kills to see if anything changes if you like.
12/15/2016 02:48:50
I can run the numbers with 5 mafia / assuming third party kills to see if anything changes if you like.
12/15/2016 02:48:50
Bijou said:The problem is that the lylo position changes depending on how many mafia we catch along the way, which is impossible to predict. And while a SK is easy to account for (just add one more night kill), doctor and vigilante intervention is not.
I already pointed out that I didn't account for third party kills. I agree there will be people with night kill powers other than the mafia this game.
I can run the numbers with 5 mafia / assuming third party kills to see if anything changes if you like.
12/15/2016 02:52:21
Answer Ryan's question when you can, fuccboiz.
12/15/2016 03:10:32
12/15/2016 03:10:32
Who is Ryan (Rhyno?)
2 weeks is good
12/15/2016 03:45:16
2 weeks is good
12/15/2016 03:45:16
I am indeed Ryan. The main reason I suggested shortening to 1 week is that is how most of the other mafia games have run, except the most recent one.
12/15/2016 03:47:07
12/15/2016 03:47:07
Ok it seems like Corvid is fine... for now
Vote: Unvote
12/15/2016 03:47:09
Vote: Unvote
12/15/2016 03:47:09
VOTE: NO LYNCH
I really dont see a point in lynching anyone right now. But Corvid seems kinda suss
12/15/2016 03:49:07
I really dont see a point in lynching anyone right now. But Corvid seems kinda suss
12/15/2016 03:49:07
If everyone could start voting yeah that'd be great.
Remember no lynch is an option
12/15/2016 03:49:47
Remember no lynch is an option
12/15/2016 03:49:47
One week would probably be better for day phases btw mods.
12/15/2016 04:07:11
12/15/2016 04:07:11
I'm not voting yet, but the only person who I can think is worth lynching is Corvid, unless they have a really good power role then it seems like a decent lynch.
Of course I like the change my mind often so this isn't my final thoughts
12/15/2016 04:21:38
Of course I like the change my mind often so this isn't my final thoughts
12/15/2016 04:21:38
okay, my 2 slices of bread:
im happy that corvid replied, but hes still sus.
im suprised that no one has brought up murkiri recently, I think hes only talked once.
VOTE: Murkiri
if he dosent talk soon, hes probs a mafia
12/15/2016 04:37:45
im happy that corvid replied, but hes still sus.
im suprised that no one has brought up murkiri recently, I think hes only talked once.
VOTE: Murkiri
if he dosent talk soon, hes probs a mafia
12/15/2016 04:37:45
Since people aren't replying I'm going to bold this.
Please vote whether you want 1 week or 2 week days, the vote will go until a majority is reached. (11 people) you can post the vote here or PM Aero or I.
12/15/2016 05:54:37
Please vote whether you want 1 week or 2 week days, the vote will go until a majority is reached. (11 people) you can post the vote here or PM Aero or I.
12/15/2016 05:54:37
Two weeks should be pretty good, it's just we are taking our time for day one as we need to gather info/reactions.
12/15/2016 06:33:41
12/15/2016 06:33:41
I'm still busy but Laggy literally look 3 posts above you.
12/15/2016 07:05:11
12/15/2016 07:05:11
Vote: 1 Week Days I've just got home, and was Doing Rouge One last night so I have yet to read much. But as I stated above, Day 1 is a hard day to kill someone. You just have pick someone and Fire. Not Firing while it gives you an extra day allows for the night to start much sooner.
12/15/2016 08:04:21
12/15/2016 08:04:21
Sup dudes,
Just to let everyone know that I haven't been fully inactive, I think I'm almost 48 hours without posting. Been reading the thread checking for updates constantly since my last post.
I don't have much to add to the discussion atm, besides that it's wishful thinking at this point to catch mafia off guard on day 1, unless town starts really applying pressure. I'm still in a favour of a day 1 lynch at this point; the arguments against it put forward so far haven't convinced me.
12/15/2016 09:38:16
Just to let everyone know that I haven't been fully inactive, I think I'm almost 48 hours without posting. Been reading the thread checking for updates constantly since my last post.
I don't have much to add to the discussion atm, besides that it's wishful thinking at this point to catch mafia off guard on day 1, unless town starts really applying pressure. I'm still in a favour of a day 1 lynch at this point; the arguments against it put forward so far haven't convinced me.
12/15/2016 09:38:16
I don't think one of these games has had a day go over a week, apart from maybe the first one so I don't think it will change much but for everyone's sanity I think it would be better to lower the timer to 1 week in case we actually go for the full time. There is only so much we can get out of a day and there would be very little left after a week.
Vote:1 Week
On the note of voting, I'm voting for Corvid as he plays the same when he was mafia, Sk and town and though there has been a slight improvement I'm still not completely sure I can trust him. Vote:Corvid
12/15/2016 09:57:02
Vote:1 Week
On the note of voting, I'm voting for Corvid as he plays the same when he was mafia, Sk and town and though there has been a slight improvement I'm still not completely sure I can trust him. Vote:Corvid
12/15/2016 09:57:02
VOTE: Three weeks, Christmas is saved, too bad about New Years Day but sacrifices must be made OK my computer's stopped making strange noises so I can post properly without fear of spontaneous combustion.
But I will happily throw my vote around at the start of the game because voting...seeing how people react under pressure is one of the best ways to push the game forward no?
@everyone who hasn't voted but is complaining about slow day, you can do something! Just because you've voted for someone does not mean you want them dead immediately.
It's what I usually do, e.g. Pokkén in which I was mafia:
And Qldsmash users in which I was town:
I can't give more examples because I've only played in two games :cryingface
I'd still like to lynch SpaceJam BUT if it seems I can't get a wagon on that and we're lynching a "weak" player no matter what then Lachlan (he has still added nothing to this discussion) and maybe Murkiri seem the much more likely targets to me. Some of our other favourite targets (Laggy, Corvid, Hydro, AutumnWind) have at least done something.
12/15/2016 10:26:08
Ghostbone said:Memeing? That's rude, I don't meme.
On the other hand, Dean threw the first vote which could have been an attempt to start a lynch train (and if anyone accuses you, just claim you were memeing).
But I will happily throw my vote around at the start of the game because voting...seeing how people react under pressure is one of the best ways to push the game forward no?
@everyone who hasn't voted but is complaining about slow day, you can do something! Just because you've voted for someone does not mean you want them dead immediately.
It's what I usually do, e.g. Pokkén in which I was mafia:
dean said:
Lynching laggy day 1 is a bad meme. I don't like memes, and i also don't like boozer. VOTE: Boozer
And Qldsmash users in which I was town:
dean said:
VOTE: Jezmo, but I will change this to Ghost if he wins tomorrow.
I can't give more examples because I've only played in two games :cryingface
I'd still like to lynch SpaceJam BUT if it seems I can't get a wagon on that and we're lynching a "weak" player no matter what then Lachlan (he has still added nothing to this discussion) and maybe Murkiri seem the much more likely targets to me. Some of our other favourite targets (Laggy, Corvid, Hydro, AutumnWind) have at least done something.
12/15/2016 10:26:08
dean said:
I'd still like to lynch SpaceJam BUT if it seems I can't get a wagon on that and we're lynching a "weak" player no matter what then Lachlan (he has still added nothing to this discussion) and maybe Murkiri seem the much more likely targets to me. Some of our other favourite targets (Laggy, Corvid, Hydro, AutumnWind) have at least done something.
Fair point.
Vote: Unvote
Vote: LachlanF
12/15/2016 10:30:10
Vote: 2 week days
Shorter days favour mafia and everyone voting for that is anti-town
/s
12/15/2016 11:05:02
Shorter days favour mafia and everyone voting for that is anti-town
/s
12/15/2016 11:05:02
Vote: 2 week days
Also yes it would be nice if those who haven't already voted did so. Voice your suspicions, vote what you think will benefit us. If you don't know what to do then read up and see if you can pin point anything suspicious. Or no lynch :/ Murkiri also seems suspicious to me. Looking like another basty .-.
Also lol at laggy for bringing up Murkiri not posting when he talked like right before (probably posted as he was writing it and didn't see it but I can't tell because it was too long ago :c)
12/15/2016 11:18:54
Also yes it would be nice if those who haven't already voted did so. Voice your suspicions, vote what you think will benefit us. If you don't know what to do then read up and see if you can pin point anything suspicious. Or no lynch :/ Murkiri also seems suspicious to me. Looking like another basty .-.
Also lol at laggy for bringing up Murkiri not posting when he talked like right before (probably posted as he was writing it and didn't see it but I can't tell because it was too long ago :c)
12/15/2016 11:18:54
By the way, if a majority isn't met by the 25th i'm just gonna keep it as 2 week days and people can end it when they see fit.
12/15/2016 12:33:01
12/15/2016 12:33:01
Damn English is hard on these drugs, i'm gonna reread the thread because i forget A lot lately
Now a person i wouldn't mind hearing from IS Luminescent A bit more. The only thing they've posted about wanting a no lynch really. Seeing as this is their first game of mafia as well they could be trying to hide? i have no feelings about him at the moment but not posting seems to be a dangerous game.
Vote: Luminescent Can you please join the discussion?
Unimpressed with Corvid/murkiri/lachlan though. Keeping us up to date with what they're thinking is a good way to help us out. perhaps explaining why you think someone is suss would allow others to take you more seriously.
other than that Ill be off my painkillers tomorrow so that will be swell.
also i like to keep the days semi accurate please. vote: 16 hour Days, 8 hour nights
12/15/2016 13:30:43
Now a person i wouldn't mind hearing from IS Luminescent A bit more. The only thing they've posted about wanting a no lynch really. Seeing as this is their first game of mafia as well they could be trying to hide? i have no feelings about him at the moment but not posting seems to be a dangerous game.
Vote: Luminescent Can you please join the discussion?
Unimpressed with Corvid/murkiri/lachlan though. Keeping us up to date with what they're thinking is a good way to help us out. perhaps explaining why you think someone is suss would allow others to take you more seriously.
other than that Ill be off my painkillers tomorrow so that will be swell.
also i like to keep the days semi accurate please. vote: 16 hour Days, 8 hour nights
12/15/2016 13:30:43
Despite me forgetting i was playing mafia for all of today until right now im still going to Vote: Two Week Days . Me forgetting the game i probably because of day 1 boringness. This isn't me trying to rush through the day but im going to Vote:Duon so he is move active i dont think he has made many posts at all and one of them was shit talking me so.
12/15/2016 15:16:44
12/15/2016 15:16:44