Same.
12/01/2017 08:35:56
Y'all are lazy!
12/02/2017 00:13:37
12/02/2017 00:13:37
Night 0:
It was a dark and mysterious night.
Nothing could be heard other than the Hoothoot's chirping in the night.
That's when IT happened.
*BANG* *CRASH* *BANG*
"Help!!!" someone shouted.
But no one was around to help them and their life had been taken from them.
MC (You), Town-Aligned protaginist has been killed
It's up the town to find out who did this!
Day 1 begins! With 7 alive it takes 4 to Lynch!
Deadline is set for 9/12/17 12:00pm AEDT!
Just a few things, Dean help me set up the game but I'll pretty much be solo modding it.
Also try your best to post as that makes the game more enjoyable for everyone.
Character claiming is also allowed, but it won't be game breaking.
12/02/2017 01:44:50
It was a dark and mysterious night.
Nothing could be heard other than the Hoothoot's chirping in the night.
That's when IT happened.
*BANG* *CRASH* *BANG*
"Help!!!" someone shouted.
But no one was around to help them and their life had been taken from them.
MC (You), Town-Aligned protaginist has been killed
It's up the town to find out who did this!
Day 1 begins! With 7 alive it takes 4 to Lynch!
Deadline is set for 9/12/17 12:00pm AEDT!
Just a few things, Dean help me set up the game but I'll pretty much be solo modding it.
Also try your best to post as that makes the game more enjoyable for everyone.
Character claiming is also allowed, but it won't be game breaking.
12/02/2017 01:44:50
Vote: Dyna_Hole
12/02/2017 01:01:40
12/02/2017 01:01:40
fuckin nice
12/02/2017 02:38:24
12/02/2017 02:38:24
Aerodrome said:
Y'all are lazy!
"Y'all are stupid!" ;)
But yes I am alive hello I like pokemon Also aero you better get that reference :(
12/02/2017 02:53:51
Aerodrome said:
Vote: Dyna_Hole
Dyna_Hole said:
fuckin nice
10/10 way to start the thread lol.
Just putting this out there, but given that there are only 7 players this game we probably need to be really careful with how we're voting today. Assuming there are at least two mafia the game could be in lynch-or-lose mode as early as Day 2.
12/02/2017 07:33:17
To get the basics out of the way, with 7 people the usual amount of mafia would be 2. If there were only 1 then the team dynamic wouldn't exist and anymore would be a near instant loss for town. I'm assuming that their is no 3rd party killer because that would further weaken town.
If we don't lynch today but lynch tomorrow, hitting town and the mafia succeeds in their kills we would lose by day two which is the same as if we were to lynch both days. The issue is that the town would have less power going into the second day if we were to hit town today.
Of course this may change if a doctor saves someone during the night but with how much information we usually get in day 1 and how little people we have in the game, I think a no lynch might be our best option.
We should still try to get as much out of today as we can, since we'll have less time then usual, however if we can't pin anything suspicious on one of us I don't think we should just lynch someone like we have in previous games.
12/02/2017 08:29:47
If we don't lynch today but lynch tomorrow, hitting town and the mafia succeeds in their kills we would lose by day two which is the same as if we were to lynch both days. The issue is that the town would have less power going into the second day if we were to hit town today.
Of course this may change if a doctor saves someone during the night but with how much information we usually get in day 1 and how little people we have in the game, I think a no lynch might be our best option.
We should still try to get as much out of today as we can, since we'll have less time then usual, however if we can't pin anything suspicious on one of us I don't think we should just lynch someone like we have in previous games.
12/02/2017 08:29:47
Windkeeper0 said:
If we don't lynch today but lynch tomorrow, hitting town and the mafia succeeds in their kills we would lose by day two which is the same as if we were to lynch both days. The issue is that the town would have less power going into the second day if we were to hit town today.
Doesn't this mean we should lynch day one though? Yanno more chances of hitting Mafia :o
I feel like we have this discussion every game and I still stand by that lynch is always better day one but if yous are all down for no lynch it's fine by me.
12/02/2017 08:59:59
I do see the merit in having the chance to hit mafia in our first lynch but since we could potentially have our last turn tomorrow and the mafia being the only people in the know, it is far easier for them to control the town in the second round of this game then they would in any other game.
Either way runs it's risk but personally I feel like we are better off with a higher ratio of town to mafia tomorrow then to risk a 2 in 7 chance of hitting a mafia member. That of course chances if we find someone acting suspiciously but for now that's what I'm thinking. I should probably note that if two townies die before tomorrow the mafia only needs to convince 1 townie to vote for another townie.
12/02/2017 09:33:05
Either way runs it's risk but personally I feel like we are better off with a higher ratio of town to mafia tomorrow then to risk a 2 in 7 chance of hitting a mafia member. That of course chances if we find someone acting suspiciously but for now that's what I'm thinking. I should probably note that if two townies die before tomorrow the mafia only needs to convince 1 townie to vote for another townie.
12/02/2017 09:33:05
BattleDolphin said:yes it was a guzma reference in the beginning :>
Aerodrome said:
Y'all are lazy!
"Y'all are stupid!" ;)
But yes I am alive hello I like pokemon Also aero you better get that reference :(
Also i think lynching today is fine, we probably have a 2 in 7 chance of hitting mafia so i like those odds Also mr l is in america rn so
12/02/2017 23:42:47
I think lynching is an alright move but i think we should wait a day and see who dies, it may give a small bit of insight as to who the mafia could be. we would need the same amount of votes tomorrow, yeah? so i think we should wait cause it them goes down to a 33% chance and i think that's reasonable with a 4-man lynch.
12/02/2017 23:53:41
12/02/2017 23:53:41
Well, ok
Vote: No lynch Actually thinking about it lynching today is still the best decision
12/03/2017 05:44:11
Vote: No lynch Actually thinking about it lynching today is still the best decision
12/03/2017 05:44:11
No lynch would be a bad choice . Assuming 2 mafia and mislynching, it would go:
Day 1: No lynch
Night 1: Town Kill (4 town/2 mafia)
Day 2: Lynch (3/2)
Night 2: Town kill (2/2)
Mafia win
If we lynch from Day 1:
Day 1: Lynch (4 town/2 mafia)
Night 1: Town kill (3/2)
Day 2: Lynch (2/2)
Mafia win
So basically if we lynch day 1 we get two chances of hitting mafia. No lynch would only give us one chance.
12/03/2017 06:31:02
Day 1: No lynch
Night 1: Town Kill (4 town/2 mafia)
Day 2: Lynch (3/2)
Night 2: Town kill (2/2)
Mafia win
If we lynch from Day 1:
Day 1: Lynch (4 town/2 mafia)
Night 1: Town kill (3/2)
Day 2: Lynch (2/2)
Mafia win
So basically if we lynch day 1 we get two chances of hitting mafia. No lynch would only give us one chance.
12/03/2017 06:31:02
Lynching incorrectly today puts us in lylo
it's more like
Day 1: Lynch (5 town/2 mafia) (2/7 chance, 28.5%)
Night 1: Town kill (4/2)
Day 2: Lynch (3/2) (2/5, 40% chance)
It's as you say though, we have 2 chances instead of just 1 by lynching.
Vote: Dyna_Hole
12/03/2017 07:45:28
it's more like
Day 1: Lynch (5 town/2 mafia) (2/7 chance, 28.5%)
Night 1: Town kill (4/2)
Day 2: Lynch (3/2) (2/5, 40% chance)
It's as you say though, we have 2 chances instead of just 1 by lynching.
Vote: Dyna_Hole
12/03/2017 07:45:28
Agreed that we should lynch, although at this point there shouldn't really be discussion as to weather we should or not.
Windkeeper proposing the no lynch gives me a bad vibe, particularly with that (effectively) being the opening post of the game start (and steering) discussion.
Dyna also leaning toward no lynch is odd but would be too straight forward.
Mafia would probably want to be disagreeing to distance themselves from eachother i.e. wind + bijou or wind + aero.
Aero also with the quick vote, I'd advise with-holding from voting for now.
12/03/2017 08:21:10
Windkeeper proposing the no lynch gives me a bad vibe, particularly with that (effectively) being the opening post of the game start (and steering) discussion.
Dyna also leaning toward no lynch is odd but would be too straight forward.
Mafia would probably want to be disagreeing to distance themselves from eachother i.e. wind + bijou or wind + aero.
Aero also with the quick vote, I'd advise with-holding from voting for now.
12/03/2017 08:21:10
We're going to be in lylo whether we lynch or not, assuming the mafia don't get prevented from night killing. I'd rather have two chances to lynch than one.
Do you reckon the mafia would pile on someone with two votes on them? Let's find out.
Vote: Dyna_Hole
12/03/2017 08:21:33
Do you reckon the mafia would pile on someone with two votes on them? Let's find out.
Vote: Dyna_Hole
12/03/2017 08:21:33
Now that the work week has started again I can procrastinate by playing forum mafia. XD
We have the lynch vs no lynch day 1 argument every game and it's pretty stale. Let's decide and move on to the interesting part of the game.
On that note, I seem to remember that I have an unfulfilled grudge against Aero for reasons I no longer remember. But who needs reasons, right? I don't think he's been day 1 lynched yet so it's his turn.
Vote: Aerodrome
12/03/2017 23:39:49
We have the lynch vs no lynch day 1 argument every game and it's pretty stale. Let's decide and move on to the interesting part of the game.
On that note, I seem to remember that I have an unfulfilled grudge against Aero for reasons I no longer remember. But who needs reasons, right? I don't think he's been day 1 lynched yet so it's his turn.
Vote: Aerodrome
12/03/2017 23:39:49
Sorry guys, have been out all yesterday and today
If Wind and Dyna dont wanna lynch that could be bad in terms of making a decision lol (we'd need 4 out of the 5 remaining)
Usual day 1 stuff for me idk what to think at all but this day is super important in such a short game so I'm not gonna vote anyone for now.
I feel like theres always that 1 guy per game who wants no lynch and they're just dumb, not necessarily mafia, so i dont feel wind is more suss than anyone else at this point
Mr L usually posts analysing everyone randomly so thats normal i guess
I dont recall Invisi usually randomly meme voting (seemingly) day 1 in previous games but idk it's been a while
I'm surprised i manage to write this much on day 1 lol
12/04/2017 11:30:09
If Wind and Dyna dont wanna lynch that could be bad in terms of making a decision lol (we'd need 4 out of the 5 remaining)
Usual day 1 stuff for me idk what to think at all but this day is super important in such a short game so I'm not gonna vote anyone for now.
I feel like theres always that 1 guy per game who wants no lynch and they're just dumb, not necessarily mafia, so i dont feel wind is more suss than anyone else at this point
Mr L usually posts analysing everyone randomly so thats normal i guess
I dont recall Invisi usually randomly meme voting (seemingly) day 1 in previous games but idk it's been a while
I'm surprised i manage to write this much on day 1 lol
12/04/2017 11:30:09
Well the odd thing with wind is he's not a dumb player at all, which is why his advocacy for a no lynch is weird.
12/04/2017 17:50:46
12/04/2017 17:50:46
I have most definitely meme voted day 1 like the last 3 games. =P Day 1 is boring - I'd rather get it over with quickly.
12/04/2017 22:14:11
12/04/2017 22:14:11
MrL said:
Well the odd thing with wind is he's not a dumb player at all, which is why his advocacy for a no lynch is weird.
I guess but this is most definitely not the first time i've seen a smart player bring up no lynch (even in IRL games)
12/05/2017 02:15:03
Sorry I haven't been on in a while. Saying we should go for a no lynch was just to get some discussion going, I don't think we should actually go for a no lynch. Since it's day 1 and there is nothing to talk about I thought I might as well try to make myself the target with something minor and see if I could get a reaction.
I'm not so sure that Dyna_Hole is mafia since the other member would likely tell them that agreeing with me would make them stand out. It is possible that mafia can't communicate during the day but I don't think he is our best target for today.
12/05/2017 06:12:55
I'm not so sure that Dyna_Hole is mafia since the other member would likely tell them that agreeing with me would make them stand out. It is possible that mafia can't communicate during the day but I don't think he is our best target for today.
12/05/2017 06:12:55
"i said something but i didnt mean it" smh
12/05/2017 06:23:04
12/05/2017 06:23:04
I will admit it was pretty poorly executed so I understand why you don't trust me on that.
12/05/2017 06:45:15
12/05/2017 06:45:15