I'm having a hard time deciding who I want to lynch. I honestly believe Exist's defence so I don't want to lynch him. JEANS seems like too much of a scapegoat but could be safeish lynch choice so I'm far happier with that. Idk what to think of BD after everything honestly, so I'm not super keen on lynching him.
I honestly want to pressure aero but given we have limited time I agree with Invisi that we should probably lynch one of the above 3. I think JEANS would be a good choice to pressure for now as he is the only one out of the spotlight in this phase.
Vote: JEANS
03/04/2019 08:08:39
Vote: JEANS
03/04/2019 08:09:37
03/04/2019 08:09:37
Come on guys, we're in crunch time now. We need you lot to be posting far more regularly! We aren't gonna get anywhere without people posting
03/04/2019 12:03:25
03/04/2019 12:03:25
Yes rise up gamers let's get this lynch.
03/04/2019 14:13:15
03/04/2019 14:13:15
Yea, I'm fine with this, atm I'm most suss of JEANS+BD. We should probably give them a chance to speak before we lynch either of them though. But I'll get us to L-2 at least. Vote: JEANS
03/04/2019 22:26:33
03/04/2019 22:26:33
Sorry I didn't realise the deadline was coming up.
It should be 4 to lynch so Jeans is at l-1 right now. Someone may want to unvote for now just in case. I can't say I feel strongly about any lynch right now so I'll wait for Jeans defense. I'll try to post something else once I get home later today.
03/05/2019 01:03:43
It should be 4 to lynch so Jeans is at l-1 right now. Someone may want to unvote for now just in case. I can't say I feel strongly about any lynch right now so I'll wait for Jeans defense. I'll try to post something else once I get home later today.
03/05/2019 01:03:43
Unvote Wait it's 5 to lynch
Vote: JEANS
03/05/2019 01:09:27
Vote: JEANS
03/05/2019 01:09:27
Nevermind my bad.
03/05/2019 01:24:06
03/05/2019 01:24:06
Even if he has a defense, what would you have us do, Maribro? No lynch? Would you mind if we lynched you instead?
03/05/2019 01:31:36
03/05/2019 01:31:36
Aerodrome said:
Even if he has a defense, what would you have us do, Maribro? No lynch? Would you mind if we lynched you instead?
I don't understand this question. How do you want me to answer this? Anyways, I don't think no lynch is the answer. I don't think lynching me is a good idea either, not sure why you suggested that. I think it's probably wise to just lynch whichever of Exist, BD and JEANS has the weakest defence. We already have a defence from two of them so yeah, just waiting on JEANS now really.
03/05/2019 02:35:47
I'm more suspicious of you than any of those three if I'm being honest.
03/05/2019 02:57:09
03/05/2019 02:57:09
Aerodrome said:
I'm more suspicious of you than any of those three if I'm being honest.
I'm more suspicious of you than those other three too, but I don't think there's enough time in this phase to really pressure you properly. If you really think I'm maf go ahead and vote for me. Maybe a dead townie is worth more than a suss alive one ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
03/05/2019 03:00:14
I agree that JEANS, BD, and me I guess seem the most suspicious at the moment. I have no excuse for my inactivity and I'll try to be more active as this game progresses.
I still feel like there's something off about aero. He's playing very aggressively, I get that this is how he normally plays, he always gives me mafia vibes, especially early game.
If JEANS doesn't say anything in a timely manner, I suppose we should lynch him. In saying that, I feel like the mafia is actually within the more active players. So the real people that I'm keeping an eye on are BD, Windkeeper, Aero, Maribro, and Invisi. None of them are giving off mafia vibes but that's exactly what I would expect from our more experienced players. And yes, I realize I mentioned almost everyone as being suspicious, I'm finding it pretty difficult to get reads on anyone. If anyone, I'm thinking BD.
03/05/2019 03:08:43
I still feel like there's something off about aero. He's playing very aggressively, I get that this is how he normally plays, he always gives me mafia vibes, especially early game.
If JEANS doesn't say anything in a timely manner, I suppose we should lynch him. In saying that, I feel like the mafia is actually within the more active players. So the real people that I'm keeping an eye on are BD, Windkeeper, Aero, Maribro, and Invisi. None of them are giving off mafia vibes but that's exactly what I would expect from our more experienced players. And yes, I realize I mentioned almost everyone as being suspicious, I'm finding it pretty difficult to get reads on anyone. If anyone, I'm thinking BD.
03/05/2019 03:08:43
we have 2 full days and it's been extended think you guys under exaggerate the time we have. as long as there's like 5 townies active late tomorrow then we dont need to fear a no lynch. I guess ill claim icecream flavour.
I'm the iconic COOKIES AND CREAM (best flavour btw).
I dont really by bd's defense tbh
it's false in that it actually proves nothing. and that exist actually defended the concept of not lynching early rather than me.
he said he wasnt defending me in his original post back in day 1. You said to have looked back through his posts and still agreed he looked 'suss af'.
what post other than saying something like 'is there a doctor' as first post day 2 suss, but he already defended that post before this interaction happened.
also you said my points against you were both the same thing
It was 1 you agreeing with him on being shallow
and 2 how hard you agreed with him (saying he's sus af)
and 3 you tried to add things that town could see suss about exist, but these were even more shallow (that me and him in kahoots)
aero probably didnt even think he was sus lol and was just looking for an excuse to throw a vote onto literally anybody because that's how he plays.
and just because you
you were still trying to push town into thinking in that direction, so I see suggesting it not add anything at all when if anybody actually does research the suggestion makes very little sense.
ok Im done with bd for now really I just wanted to finish off that pathway. Town doesnt seem to see anything im seeing so potentially im just biased against BD from him suggesting me and exist. (and exist says just now he's most suss too, so only ones against him would be biased)
really I want to move onto maribro, day 1 he was semi pushing on an easy lynch when In a low power game, I dont really understand policy lynching day 1. Even in a highpower game like last game a mafia was lynched day 1(with help from dean to be fair)
then with 2 days left in the day he wants to for another 'safe' lynch.
I could understand this more on last day maybe like 12 hours left but it just seems to early for it, everyone was pretty readily active before so pushing for that play so early seemingly has no faith.
Then he makes statements like
' If you really think I'm maf go ahead and vote for me.Maybe a dead townie is worth more than a suss alive one ¯\_(ツ)_/¯' when aero is trying to actually get a discussion started, maribro throws quick short posts that really hold nothing of value, trying to get town back onto the 'quick lynch' path. and then he holds the fact we have limited time against us, multiple times throughout his posts to get us on quicklynch path again. there was no nightkill, so we potentially could not have much more info to go off of day 3 aswell. and mafia could just keep trying to stall the days until town feels obliged to go for quicklynches.
also just the interactions between aero and maribro. I think it's pretty likely one of the two is mafia, and I honestly find maribro more suss than aero rightnow.
oh and I thought i'd add against the claims im 'inconsistent tones'
yeah so I'm trying to shitpost less than I did when I played mafia 2 years ago, but im still me mostly... the shitpost in this game the whole maribro thing was about something not even relevant to the game, it was more meta on maribros excuses. when in previous game id make a similar post actually about something, and it would also be all i posted... when this time ive actually made effort to analyze posts and give my thoughts on things.
Vote:Maribro
i hope this post is formatted good and works
03/05/2019 05:41:11
I'm the iconic COOKIES AND CREAM (best flavour btw).
I dont really by bd's defense tbh
BattleDolphin said:
I'm definitely not trying to suck up to Aero lool, I've already said I hate how he plays and that continues to now (as he's still just joining every train and not commenting on them until later if ever lmao)
This is literally me agreeing with something objective?? Exist defended you and not Blaze. No one's saying that's false lmao.
it's false in that it actually proves nothing. and that exist actually defended the concept of not lynching early rather than me.
BattleDolphin said:
This was also before Exist defended himself
he said he wasnt defending me in his original post back in day 1. You said to have looked back through his posts and still agreed he looked 'suss af'.
BattleDolphin said:
On the other hand tho reading through Exists post history omfg I totally agree Aero he looks suss af atm, idk how this has been let slip till now LOL?
I actually wanna pressure him a bit so I'll VOTE: Exist
what post other than saying something like 'is there a doctor' as first post day 2 suss, but he already defended that post before this interaction happened.
also you said my points against you were both the same thing
BattleDolphin said:
I thought I had more to say in response to Jeans' stuff about me but I realised he said the same thing twice LOL (me agreeing with aero that exist didn't defend blaze)
It was 1 you agreeing with him on being shallow
and 2 how hard you agreed with him (saying he's sus af)
and 3 you tried to add things that town could see suss about exist, but these were even more shallow (that me and him in kahoots)
aero probably didnt even think he was sus lol and was just looking for an excuse to throw a vote onto literally anybody because that's how he plays.
and just because you
BattleDolphin said:
JEANS said:
aero:Going through exists posts he seemed adamant on defending JEANS but that zeal was never shown on defending Blaze.
bd:That's true (about exist), potentially in kahoots you reckon? Something to keep in mind :o
Also do you not know what "you reckon" means, and I never even said I agree I just said people should keep in mind the potential.
you were still trying to push town into thinking in that direction, so I see suggesting it not add anything at all when if anybody actually does research the suggestion makes very little sense.
ok Im done with bd for now really I just wanted to finish off that pathway. Town doesnt seem to see anything im seeing so potentially im just biased against BD from him suggesting me and exist. (and exist says just now he's most suss too, so only ones against him would be biased)
really I want to move onto maribro, day 1 he was semi pushing on an easy lynch when In a low power game, I dont really understand policy lynching day 1. Even in a highpower game like last game a mafia was lynched day 1(with help from dean to be fair)
then with 2 days left in the day he wants to for another 'safe' lynch.
I could understand this more on last day maybe like 12 hours left but it just seems to early for it, everyone was pretty readily active before so pushing for that play so early seemingly has no faith.
Then he makes statements like
' If you really think I'm maf go ahead and vote for me.Maybe a dead townie is worth more than a suss alive one ¯\_(ツ)_/¯' when aero is trying to actually get a discussion started, maribro throws quick short posts that really hold nothing of value, trying to get town back onto the 'quick lynch' path. and then he holds the fact we have limited time against us, multiple times throughout his posts to get us on quicklynch path again. there was no nightkill, so we potentially could not have much more info to go off of day 3 aswell. and mafia could just keep trying to stall the days until town feels obliged to go for quicklynches.
also just the interactions between aero and maribro. I think it's pretty likely one of the two is mafia, and I honestly find maribro more suss than aero rightnow.
oh and I thought i'd add against the claims im 'inconsistent tones'
Maribro said:
JEANS - Has made just 4 posts for the game so far. A struggle to read considering the vastly inconsistent tone between posts. From the humble "I'm an easy lynch, don't lynch me" to the whatever this is: "maribro was like woa guys I can post way more day 2 than day 1 what he actually meant by that was is he can only make real posts just as often as before, but now we get updates and delays as to when they'll happen. heh." IDK. Yeah JEANS is an easy lynch given everything but… he's just so inconsistent tonally. I don't trust it atm.
yeah so I'm trying to shitpost less than I did when I played mafia 2 years ago, but im still me mostly... the shitpost in this game the whole maribro thing was about something not even relevant to the game, it was more meta on maribros excuses. when in previous game id make a similar post actually about something, and it would also be all i posted... when this time ive actually made effort to analyze posts and give my thoughts on things.
Vote:Maribro
i hope this post is formatted good and works
03/05/2019 05:41:11
If nothing else, your taste in ice-cream is on point. I think I'm going to vote against the person who makes the most sense to me at the moment.
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/05/2019 05:56:01
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/05/2019 05:56:01
Unvote
03/05/2019 07:55:39
03/05/2019 07:55:39
JEANS said:
really I want to move onto maribro, day 1 he was semi pushing on an easy lynch when In a low power game, I dont really understand policy lynching day 1.
I wasn't trying to policy lynch you, your major post that phase was weird and it made me suss of you.
JEANS said:
then with 2 days left in the day he wants to for another 'safe' lynch.
I could understand this more on last day maybe like 12 hours left but it just seems to early for it, everyone was pretty readily active before so pushing for that play so early seemingly has no faith.
There's a lot wrong with this. I'm not going for a "safe" lynch, you're one of my top suspects (for reasons I provided in both my posts). I just think the person I want to lynch the most (Aero) is probably not in a position to be lynched this phase due to how late we are so there's no point pushing that. I think you're also somewhat likely to flip maf. Also people have been BLATANTLY inactive for the past 5 days or whatever, so I entirely disagree with good activity being a reason not to lynch anyone I've mentioned.
JEANS said:
Then he makes statements like
' If you really think I'm maf go ahead and vote for me.Maybe a dead townie is worth more than a suss alive one ¯\_(ツ)_/¯' when aero is trying to actually get a discussion started, maribro throws quick short posts that really hold nothing of value
I don't think they hold nothing of value, I genuinely didn't really understand wtf Aero was getting at so I was just posting to try and answer what I thought he was getting at. I don't know really, that's pretty subjective tbh.
JEANS said:
, trying to get town back onto the 'quick lynch' path. and then he holds the fact we have limited time against us, multiple times throughout his posts to get us on quicklynch path again.
If you read my posts I'm trying to encourage activity, not "quicklynching". We've had several people (YOU included) not post for nearly a week. That's straight up not good enough. If people aren't posting enough we can't learn shit.
JEANS said:
there was no nightkill, so we potentially could not have much more info to go off of day 3 aswell. and mafia could just keep trying to stall the days until town feels obliged to go for quicklynches.
Mafia win by killing people btw, this isn't a recommended strategy at all. If there is a cop and they keep stalling, they're probably gonna lose to that. If there isn't a cop and they keep stalling then they're just making the game go on longer than it needs to. It's not optimal to do this at all.
JEANS said:
also just the interactions between aero and maribro. I think it's pretty likely one of the two is mafia, and I honestly find maribro more suss than aero rightnow.
Not necessarily true, I played a game on Mafia Universe where someone thought I was mafia from day one cos I called him out and it nearly threw the whole game. Just cos two people argue does not necessarily mean they are on opposite teams. Townies can argue.
03/05/2019 15:01:57
T-2 days, and the votes look fairly split. What's the plan boys?
03/05/2019 22:47:29
03/05/2019 22:47:29
They both make good points, lets lynch battledolphin.
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/05/2019 23:52:01
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/05/2019 23:52:01
BD's defence definitely the least convincing to me…
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/06/2019 00:36:28
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/06/2019 00:36:28
WELP I definitely didn't wanna have to do this but I suppose I need to now lmao
I am Rum and Raisin Ice Cream, Town Roleblocker.
At first at the start of the game I was a big stupidhead and thought I was getting trolled because I thought this was a vanilla game with no roles so I posted this:
But then I quickly realised roleblocking also stops the Mafia kill so like ahhhh idk why I'm this role??
But yeah anyway I roleblocked Maribro n1 because I thought he was scary and there was no night kill so like high chance he's Mafia?
I was gonna claim but then y'all were like "it doesn't prove there's a doc at all!" and that kinda scared me because if Maribro wasn't Mafia (and the doc did just successfully save) and we lynched him we'd probably be fucked at that point because I'd claimed lmao
And that's still the situation now I guess :(
I guess I'm gonna VOTE: Maribro again anyway, I don't have anything else close to hard evidence on people
Also give me ideas on who to roleblock next so I can prove this to you guys somehow
03/06/2019 01:41:54
I am Rum and Raisin Ice Cream, Town Roleblocker.
At first at the start of the game I was a big stupidhead and thought I was getting trolled because I thought this was a vanilla game with no roles so I posted this:
BattleDolphin said:
With this kind of game (idk how many roles there are if literally any) I would like some sort of discussion before we actually lynch someone tho D:
Lmao by idk how many I mean I basically expect 0 LOL judging by how asa was like this is a learn to play Mafia!!
But then I quickly realised roleblocking also stops the Mafia kill so like ahhhh idk why I'm this role??
But yeah anyway I roleblocked Maribro n1 because I thought he was scary and there was no night kill so like high chance he's Mafia?
I was gonna claim but then y'all were like "it doesn't prove there's a doc at all!" and that kinda scared me because if Maribro wasn't Mafia (and the doc did just successfully save) and we lynched him we'd probably be fucked at that point because I'd claimed lmao
And that's still the situation now I guess :(
I guess I'm gonna VOTE: Maribro again anyway, I don't have anything else close to hard evidence on people
Also give me ideas on who to roleblock next so I can prove this to you guys somehow
03/06/2019 01:41:54
Hello yes im back from Phantom and read through the things. Teehee vote: battledolphin teehee
I’m at work atm, will try to do a proper post tonight!
03/06/2019 01:42:48
I’m at work atm, will try to do a proper post tonight!
03/06/2019 01:42:48
So apparently I miscounted days and we're actually on the last day now.
Also we're at L-1 and we haven't yet evaluated BD's claim so no quickhammering you mafia scum pls someone unvote ASAP That said, I'm not sure if I believe this claim, a town roleblocker in a vanilla game just seems... off Also JEANS told us his flavour without saying his role? Is he trying to hide something? From what I've seen so far I get the feeling the flavours don't actually have anything to do with the roles but I might be wrong.
03/06/2019 01:58:00
Also we're at L-1 and we haven't yet evaluated BD's claim so no quickhammering you mafia scum pls someone unvote ASAP That said, I'm not sure if I believe this claim, a town roleblocker in a vanilla game just seems... off Also JEANS told us his flavour without saying his role? Is he trying to hide something? From what I've seen so far I get the feeling the flavours don't actually have anything to do with the roles but I might be wrong.
03/06/2019 01:58:00
Invisi said:
That said, I'm not sure if I believe this claim, a town roleblocker in a vanilla game just seems... off
YEAH I AGREEEEE
03/06/2019 02:39:52
I looked back at the set ups and roleblocker is only ever placed on the mafia's side. Asa could have put a town roleblocker in but it is pretty unlikely. I think battledolphin is a pretty safe bet for today. We should wait until closer to the deadline though to make sure we squeeze as much information out as possible. I'm on my phone rn so sorry about the formatting if it's a mess.
03/06/2019 02:45:15
03/06/2019 02:45:15