This is a really weird situation, I dunno what to make of this. Assuming MrL isn't lying, our best choice is still BattleDolphin because verifying that he's a VT lets us kill off MrL the next day.
Vote: BattleDolphin That's pretty decisive evidence, I figure since we're not in LyLo we can just lynch BattleDolphin and if he isn't anti-town lynch MrL the next day. We didn't you tell us this earlier? Why didn't you tell us day 2? Why did you wait until there was less than 24 hours of day 3 to tell us?
Aerodrome said: We need to assume the worst, and that is:
No cop No doctor SK exists
Do you think the entire town is filled with VTs or something lol.
That wouldn't surprise me to be honest. I think this game is less power role heavy than usual.
MrL said: To be honest, given all that you've said, you'd be the best lynch to make. You would give town the most information based off of what role you end up being and what assertions you've made. Quite frankly i'd be willing to bet that you're SK or mafia rather than town.
I'm down for that if it helps town, although I don't see how lynching a townie assists town in this situation. =)
MrL said:Is my rushed post at UQ 28 really all you have to think I'm mafia Aero? I already said all I have to say about it.
I believe either you or Maribro are mafia. I'm starting to think less that both of you are and maybe only one of you are. It's entirely possible you both are though. Maribro has said that he's willing to be lynched to prove he isn't Mafia, but are you? You seem much more resistant to the idea.
MrL said:Aero's playing irrationally but unfortunately that's not exactly unusual. If anything I'd say he's SK, don't think he's mafia though.
MrL said:Going for a real hard read but tbh I think there are 3 mafia with laggy being there to fill up space. Those three would be Maribro, Extra and Battledolphin imo. Just from how they've been interacting etc.
Maribro has been very quiet and has played that off as being busy + a roleclaim that literally means nothing as we know mafia have fake roles to claim.
We need to assume the worst, and that is:
No cop No doctor SK exists
With an SK in the game and 4 mafia, that would make the anti town roles cover, like, 35% of the player base?
For a game of 14 people, 3.75 true anti town roles would be the appropriate number, thinking there would be 5 is silly.
MrL said:Extra has been playing the same as he has been every time he's mafia. I think that yes, maybe he might've straight-up quit if laggy was on his mafia team, which makes me think that there's 3 mafia with laggy as an extra, as opposed to laggy taking up that extra spot.
I don't buy this.
MrL said:Battledolphin - Was away for a week and dean knew, which yes he could've easily PM'd him, but in my experience in mafia, they'd either post in here to let everyone know, or if they were mafia they'd just tell them in the mafia discord. When battledolphin did return, he was very inactive in the second and initially today, having to be called up by the actual players, not the admin. This suggests to me that even though he hasn't been active here, he's been active in the discord.
This is a possible safeguard to protect Battledolphin if you do get lynched and are mafia. Worth noting this down I think.
MrL said:As for the SK/Vig discussion, I think possible SK is Aero with possible Vig as Luminouslucas.
Aero's playing similarly to when he was SK last, and Luminous' change in style/confidence may be to do with a change in importance of his role.
Nah, if I was SK I would have killed Bijou already. The more I think about it the more the MrL/BattleDolphin combination appeals to me actually.
HydroPimp was targeted because he seemed pretty pro-town.
I think the best lynch might actually be MrL, since he jumped on my bandwagon super fast (again). If MrL flips mafia we can probably safely assume that Maribro is town. I think MrL is the safest lynch today.