My reasoning behind agreeing with you and voting JEANS is because I am literally the only person who doesn't think JEANS is scum. I will trust the better judgement of those who have fallen. Vote: JEANS
Vote: Windkeeper We’re in a situation where we can lynch two people but there are three possibilities. I haven’t noticed any stuff ups from any of the players so lynching the player who is least likely to mess up as mafia seems like our best bet.
Okay, I'm still on the fence about this all. Aero said you were first on the BD train. JEANS countered that he was the one to cast suspicion onto BD in the first place. Also, JEANS was first on the train from what I can see.
Unvote I have to think about this Okay, so if Maribro is mafia, killing aero was an excellent play. JEANS makes a valid point. He was the reason the BD train started. Aero being killed is best for Maribro if he's mafia and worst for JEANS if he's mafia. It all could be a wine in front of me play. The only question is, are these the sorts of people that poison your glass so you drink it and die, or poison their own glass knowing you will switch them. I'm inclined to believe that JEANS is town.
I feel like shooting aero was a bad idea on mafia’s part. Aero layed out his whole plan in that post and now all that’s happened is what he has said is 100% trustworthy. This seems more to me like a JEANS play than a Windkeeper one. Vote: Jeans
Applying Occham’s Razor, I think it’s more likely that the doc got lucky than asa deciding to put a town alligned role blocker in the game. Also, as you yourself brought up BD, you mentioned that you thought there would be very few power roles. If you really were a town alligned role blocker, why would you mention this? Did you not consider that you would potentially have to contradict yourself if people started suspecting you? It just makes you seem more sus. Vote: BattleDolphin
I know this is probably a logical fallacy of some kind but the fact that he’s claiming role blocker instead of doctor makes his claim seem slightly more believable. Claiming doctor would have made the real doctor, assuming they exist, consider counter claiming. This gives maf another piece of information.
I agree that JEANS, BD, and me I guess seem the most suspicious at the moment. I have no excuse for my inactivity and I'll try to be more active as this game progresses.
I still feel like there's something off about aero. He's playing very aggressively, I get that this is how he normally plays, he always gives me mafia vibes, especially early game.
If JEANS doesn't say anything in a timely manner, I suppose we should lynch him. In saying that, I feel like the mafia is actually within the more active players. So the real people that I'm keeping an eye on are BD, Windkeeper, Aero, Maribro, and Invisi. None of them are giving off mafia vibes but that's exactly what I would expect from our more experienced players. And yes, I realize I mentioned almost everyone as being suspicious, I'm finding it pretty difficult to get reads on anyone. If anyone, I'm thinking BD.
Hey all, I have been nudged so I better try to say something productive. I have a free hour after lectures today so I’ll write up a post then. Or before depending on how boring the lectures are.
Okay, so hi. I guess I kinda see what you guys mean with my posts being suspicious. I defended JEANS because I didn't want the day to end without any discussion. I didn't defend blaze because I kinda didn't check the thread until after the lynch. If I had been active, I probably still would have let the lynch happen because memeing around isn't really a normal reaction for most people who are put under the hammer. I found it pretty bizarre to be honest. Anyway, I'm claiming to be Butter pecan Ice-Cream a vanilla townie. My proof? I don't even know what a pecan is, I can't be making this up. In the case you guys do decide to lynch me, I would like to give my thoughts. These thoughts don't have a super solid basis but I'm thinking aero seems a little bit scary. Day 1 he was way too confident about lynching blaze. More confident then anyone has any right to be. Call this post deflection if you would like but if it were, I would attempt to deflect onto a target who seems more likely mafia like maribro. My defense is in my previous post. If people still want to lynch me after that, there's not much I can do about it so I may as well post my thoughts in hope that they become useful for town.
Okay, good to hear no killing n1 isn’t unheard of. I’ll try my best not to go full retard. Also I’m not sure what doc fishing is but if you’re saying I’m trying to make doc claim, I’m not stupid. That just means we lose our doc. I guess it doesn’t matter if doc guessed correctly. If they did, we get potentially an extra confirmed townie later in the game but it doesn’t change anything now.
Honestly, I'm not feeling the JEANS lynch just yet. He's defended himself as well as anyone could hope for day 1. The speed at which that train happened scares me a little bit. Don't get me wrong, voting because of memes is fine but I think we all realised last game that on day 1, there is still a lot to be said and a lot that can be found out by pressuring different players. We don't have enough information about how JEANS plays as the different factions to determine whether his response is in or out of character so we should at least figure out our options first. As an aside, if anyone defends themselves with "Go ahead, Lynch me." I will gladly hammer you if I'm not already on the vote train.