so either the entirety of light are on the train again and theres 1 dark on it also
or
theres 3 light on the train and all of extra laggy and maribro are mafia
04/21/2019 02:18:02
Light outnumbers dark by 3 here
Asa, LtLongshot, Dean, JonCheee, Bijou, Windkeeper, BattleDolphin, Blaze
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
Hmmm With this info of course
04/21/2019 02:26:01
Asa, LtLongshot, Dean, JonCheee, Bijou, Windkeeper, BattleDolphin, Blaze
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
Hmmm With this info of course
Which leaves four of these are anti town (and are Light Mafia):Oh that means if it's 0-3 on the train, Extra must be the last light mafia
Asa, Windkeeper, JonCheee, Dean, Extra
And two of these are anti town (and are Dark Mafia):
Blaze, Maribro, BattleDolphin, Laggy, Longshot, Bijou.
04/21/2019 02:26:01
Aerodrome said:
There's literally no chance the game is 4-4-8 btw LOL, I'd be surprised if it was 3-3-10 but I think 2-2-12 is more likely.
4-4-8 basically means we instantly lose after like night 2 if both scum factions hit us instead of the other mafia faction.
04/21/2019 02:26:10
BattleDolphin said:
THE LIGHT OUTNUMBER THE DARK BY TWO ON THIS TRAIN KMS
Asa, Boozer, Aerodrome (confirmed dark), Ghost (confirmed dark), Windkeeper, JonCheee, Dean, Extra, Mr L
THAT MAKES (if boozer is telling the truth):
Which leaves four of these are anti town (and are not sided with Ghost/Aero):
Asa, Windkeeper, JonCheee, Dean, Extra
Well dean is definitely town so asa, Windkeeper, JonCheee and extra are mafia.
I've been iffy on JonCheee since day 1 so imma Vote: JonCheee
BattleDolphin said:
And two of these are anti town (and are sided with Ghost/Aero):
Blaze, Maribro, BattleDolphin, Laggy, Longshot, Bijou.
Well we know Bijou is town, I trust Longshot's VT claim and I KNOW I'm town so that leaves Blaze, BD and Laggy.
BIG THINK.
04/21/2019 02:26:21
Again, thoughts?
04/21/2019 02:26:55
04/21/2019 02:26:55
This is very condeming for Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper. While between us its a 1 in 3. Of ocourse if boozer is telling the truth
04/21/2019 02:27:06
04/21/2019 02:27:06
Why is dean definitely town?
04/21/2019 02:27:30
04/21/2019 02:27:30
i dont think light would pile all of their players on the lynch train again, knowing theres a sensor in the game, so im inclined to think theres 3 light 0 dark on the train
im thinking that the remaining mafia are:
light: extra, dean, joncheee, windkeeper. im gonna assume here that asas claim of bodyguard is correct
dark: laggy, marioboro. these are the only possible darks remaining IF 3 light 0 dark on train
04/21/2019 02:27:39
im thinking that the remaining mafia are:
light: extra, dean, joncheee, windkeeper. im gonna assume here that asas claim of bodyguard is correct
dark: laggy, marioboro. these are the only possible darks remaining IF 3 light 0 dark on train
04/21/2019 02:27:39
Vote: JonChee Im on this train
04/21/2019 02:28:02
04/21/2019 02:28:02
I agree with blaze about aeros post about 4-4-8,so I reckon boozer is telling the truth
04/21/2019 02:29:02
04/21/2019 02:29:02
So here's what I'm thinking.
Why didn't asa die last night? If he's telling the truth about his elite status then I'm very surprised that a mafia team would risk shooting anyone else.
Aero's gambit on asa doesn't really make sense unless Dark faction was extremely confident that asa was mafia. I'm thinking that it might be possible that Ghost tracked asa Day 1 and saw him visit Ghost? (I'm not sure if results from an investigative mafioso are relayed to the rest of a team if they die that night), or if Dark had another investigative role.
04/21/2019 02:31:19
Why didn't asa die last night? If he's telling the truth about his elite status then I'm very surprised that a mafia team would risk shooting anyone else.
Aero's gambit on asa doesn't really make sense unless Dark faction was extremely confident that asa was mafia. I'm thinking that it might be possible that Ghost tracked asa Day 1 and saw him visit Ghost? (I'm not sure if results from an investigative mafioso are relayed to the rest of a team if they die that night), or if Dark had another investigative role.
04/21/2019 02:31:19
Maribro, if Dean is town then you MUST be Mafia.
04/21/2019 02:31:42
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
04/21/2019 02:31:42
I have a hard time believing Boozer just because of the doubter in my head. Honestly kinda wish Boozer had died last night so we could confirm/deny any of this shit
04/21/2019 02:32:01
04/21/2019 02:32:01
Invisi, can we ask about what Aero's role did?
04/21/2019 02:32:24
04/21/2019 02:32:24
A few things im confused about is why Dean is definitely town @Maribro, can you elaborate on that please?
And why Boozer is 100% Mafia, I dont really think what youve written would be sufficient to write him off as mafia but i will check this out, do you have a certain pages where this was happening?
04/21/2019 02:33:50
And why Boozer is 100% Mafia, I dont really think what youve written would be sufficient to write him off as mafia but i will check this out, do you have a certain pages where this was happening?
dean said:
Boozer is 100% mafia. Four mafia per team isn't a realistic possibility, his actions on Day 2 didn't make sense if he actually was the sensor and knew what he did (I said this during the morning but no one listened), and he and Aero were way way way too happy to cover for themselves on Friday. Boozer is the last Dark mafia.
04/21/2019 02:33:50
Fug I want Bijou back already
04/21/2019 02:37:15
04/21/2019 02:37:15
Also I trust that BD is VT as to his reaction to Bijou's Is this a madness game made me heavily think he is VT. and from is post earlier about the dark mafia being a 1 in 3 that would leave Blaze as dark mafia.
04/21/2019 02:44:47
04/21/2019 02:44:47
BattleDolphin said:
Maribro, if Dean is town then you MUST be Mafia.
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
I wonder why I'd be trying to sacrifice myself like this then 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
04/21/2019 02:45:16
doing the math
04/21/2019 02:45:20
04/21/2019 02:45:20
Ok I have to go clock in at work in like 10 minutes I’ll try to internalise all this and get back to you guys in the evening
04/21/2019 02:46:43
04/21/2019 02:46:43
Maribro said:
BattleDolphin said:
Maribro, if Dean is town then you MUST be Mafia.
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
I wonder why I'd be trying to sacrifice myself like this then 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Yes I am wondering a bunch about you LMAO
04/21/2019 02:51:23
Blaze, let's think that Boozer thought that there were three mafiosi on each team (because he said that's what he thought).
If he was telling the truth, he knew that three of these six players were mafia: asa, Aerodrome, Windkeeper0, JonCheee, dean, Extra. Even guessing blindly that's 50%.
He also knew that two of these seven players were not on the wagon: Bijou, Blaze, BattleDolphin, Maribro, ThatLaggyPerson, LtLongshot. That's 33%.
So if he was taking a stab in the dark, why would you go for the 33% instead of the 50%?
On Day 2 he made zero actions that were consistent with the knowledge that he supposedly knew.
Look at how happy Aero was to throw about "I believe Boozer" and "I think Boozer is town" about through the bottom of Page 25 / top of Page 26. This post in particular stands out:
Boozer was also happy to throw shade at people that voted for Aerodrome.
04/21/2019 02:53:17
If he was telling the truth, he knew that three of these six players were mafia: asa, Aerodrome, Windkeeper0, JonCheee, dean, Extra. Even guessing blindly that's 50%.
He also knew that two of these seven players were not on the wagon: Bijou, Blaze, BattleDolphin, Maribro, ThatLaggyPerson, LtLongshot. That's 33%.
So if he was taking a stab in the dark, why would you go for the 33% instead of the 50%?
On Day 2 he made zero actions that were consistent with the knowledge that he supposedly knew.
Boozer said:If he knew this then wtf were his actions all throughout the day about?
Just lynch asa ez
50/50 if hes mafia or not !!
Look at how happy Aero was to throw about "I believe Boozer" and "I think Boozer is town" about through the bottom of Page 25 / top of Page 26. This post in particular stands out:
Aerodrome said:I feel like I made some reasonable points but he just discredits my argument without addressing it and tries to establish in our minds again that Boozer is town.
Ah, BD I think Dean just wants to make Boozer look stupid. He's succeeded btw. But I still think Boozer is town.
Boozer was also happy to throw shade at people that voted for Aerodrome.
Boozer said:Even though it was basically the same group of players on the asa bandwagon as the Aerodrome wagon? Anyway judging by his D1 sensor data there shouldn't have been any distinction between Aerodrome and asa so not sure why he'd defend Aerodrome and not asa.
Quite a few potential light mafias switching to aero vote :thinking:
04/21/2019 02:53:17
BattleDolphin said:
Maribro said:
BattleDolphin said:
Maribro, if Dean is town then you MUST be Mafia.
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
I wonder why I'd be trying to sacrifice myself like this then 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Yes I am wondering a bunch about you LMAO
Okay you tell me, why would I do this?
04/21/2019 02:57:56
Maribro said:
BattleDolphin said:
Maribro said:
BattleDolphin said:
Maribro, if Dean is town then you MUST be Mafia.
So either:
0 Dark and 3 Light on the train which means that:
Maribro and Laggy are Dark Mafia (as they're not on the train), 3 of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, Windkeeper are Light Mafia
OR:
1 Dark and 4 Light on the train which means:
Blaze, LT or BattleDolphin is Dark Mafia and all of Asa, Dean, JonCheee, and Windkeeper are Light Mafia
I wonder why I'd be trying to sacrifice myself like this then 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Yes I am wondering a bunch about you LMAO
Okay you tell me, why would I do this?
Because you think Boozer is lying also? I suck at this game lmao
04/21/2019 03:00:51
well, i didnt want to draw any possible attention to the fact that i have sensor data knowledge until my x shots were done. later in the day when the train was on me and there was like an hour left i was forced to reveal it as to keep myself alive, hence why then i was willing to go the 50% route.
i already said why i was thinking aero was most likely speaking the truth lol. didnt think hed be so dumb as to basically kill himself
is there any particular reason your so adamant that 4 man mafias is a realistic impossibility, dean? that definitely reads that your trying to dissuade town from pursuing that line of thinking for your factions own gain.
04/21/2019 03:03:24
i already said why i was thinking aero was most likely speaking the truth lol. didnt think hed be so dumb as to basically kill himself
is there any particular reason your so adamant that 4 man mafias is a realistic impossibility, dean? that definitely reads that your trying to dissuade town from pursuing that line of thinking for your factions own gain.
04/21/2019 03:03:24