Oml this is insanely annoying to read I'll see y'all tomorrow LMAO
04/01/2019 01:38:10
There was no "he is dead anyways just lynch him". It was more to question if should we lynch someone else who was sus or leave the doctor for dead to the mafia.
Even if he couldn't target himself he would have been super dead, which kinda defeats the point of this comment
Even if he is a poor player during the day Doc role can still be used in a powerful position at night making him a prime target for the mafia. Now im gonna go play katamari on the walls of text.
04/01/2019 01:45:04
Even if he couldn't target himself he would have been super dead, which kinda defeats the point of this comment
but I don't think JEANS was necessarily 100% dead, both mafia factions could have had a "oh the other one will do the dirty deed instead" attitude
Even if he is a poor player during the day Doc role can still be used in a powerful position at night making him a prime target for the mafia. Now im gonna go play katamari on the walls of text.
04/01/2019 01:45:04
Maribro said:We can keep going if you want but I think I've found something a little more concrete to move on to.
dean said:
Yeah whatever my computer froze when I was typing a response to Marioboro so I'll put a raincheck on that until day 2 if we're both still alive.
Will move on to something else after lunch.
:*
If I wrap all my posts inside quote tags I think they're a little less annoying to read.
04/01/2019 01:55:43
@Dean its really hard to post cos this popup is covering my entire screen but yeah my posts dont look too good LOL
i legitimately thought he was mafia though plesse undertsand Vote: windkeeper
Ah well lets see where this leads
04/01/2019 02:02:46
i legitimately thought he was mafia though plesse undertsand Vote: windkeeper
Ah well lets see where this leads
04/01/2019 02:02:46
reading deans long post was actually painful im sorry would anyone begrudge me if i give my thoughts tomorrow
at least i got to roll it up in a ball after i was done oh and every time you make a post or refresh the thing the popup comes up ughhhh
04/01/2019 02:43:03
at least i got to roll it up in a ball after i was done oh and every time you make a post or refresh the thing the popup comes up ughhhh
04/01/2019 02:43:03
I want to respond to the recent happenings but trying to read everything on a mobile with all these little boxes and then fighting with pop ups and shit is kind of annoying so I'll postpone this temporarily.
04/01/2019 03:37:40
04/01/2019 03:37:40
katamari minigame will defeat light and dark, easy
04/01/2019 08:05:32
04/01/2019 08:05:32
Time for some day 1 A N A L Y S I S
--------
Aerodrome: Voted 8 different times LOL. I guess he's being consistent. I've already talked a bit about why I think he's suss but let's look at some of his posting again anyways…
Rereading his posts he hasn't contributed much besides providing some info about game setup. He paid almost no attention to anyone who was suss of him and didn't respond to anyone. He was very, very adamant JEANS was maf but never really explained why. Just said "I luv bandwagons" a lot. Made a lot of posts without really saying anything. Good player that is definitely capable of more. What are your reads atm, Aero? You haven't provided any thus far.
--------
Asa: Incredibly aggressive towards JEANS but I think the tension between those two explains at least some of that. I honestly can't say that anyone looks too suss for lynching JEANS because a lot of the analysis posts of JEANS made him look very suss but I honestly think once he claimed people should have backed off. There isn't much else to look at from asa really. He didn't make too much noise before pushing hard for a JEANS lynch and I disagree with his thoughts on Bijou being scummy. There's one thing I do think looks a bit dodgy though:
Reeks of arrogance. I wonder where you stand now given that JEANS flipped town.
--------
BattleDolphin:
This post is just so weird. I know it looked like I was sucking up to windkeeper early on too but idk, I just didn't do it in this way? Maybe I did lol. Anyways…
This is very wishy-washy language. Not committing to reading JEANS at all. Seems kinda like he's avoiding the burden of a read.
Soft call out on JonCheee, doesn't commit to the vote. Don't really agree with what he's said either, I think Jon is suss for different reasons. I don't think he accused half the game at all. I also think the majority of players ignored the dean vs. Maribro discussion or at the very least only acknowledged it. Nobody besides Bijou really got involved in it.
Dunno what to think of BD overall. He's defo on my suss radar though.
--------
Bijou: I think given what happened in the last day phase, it's pretty clear to me Bijou is town. I don't think mafia would want to rush to defend people as obviously suss as JEANS unless they were of the same alignment. I just can't see it being an optimal play for Scummy Bijou to defend JEANS and discuss with JEANS as much as he did. Giving all that information away isn't an optimal play for mafia. Maybe it's a wifom moment but I just can't see Bijou being scum at this stage.
--------
Blaze: Hasn't contributed enough. A suspicious lack of posts too, may just be taking a new approach to mafia given the discussions he's had with people about the game. I do think overall I'm just getting clueless townie vibes from him though.
--------
Boozer: Has contributed very little and as such is difficult to analyse. I think he's giving me town vibes but boozer's weird posting style tends to look "friendlier" than is necessarily true. Would appreciate it if you posted some reads you have.
--------
dean: I'm gonna keep this brief but you're absolutely my strongest town read. I'm very confident that you're town this game.
--------
Extra: Obviously has also contributed little overall but at the very least, has been vocal about one read, which I kinda agree with. Had the wrong read on MrL though but at least none of us have to chase that path. Was also wrong about JEANS unfortunately. I think his posts have been earnest overall and is defo a town lean for me at this stage.
--------
Laggy: Has contributed fuck all to be honest, after a decent showing in the last game, I was expecting more from him. It isn't that he's been… bad per se. It's just like Boozer, MrL, Aero (to a lesser extent) and Blaze, he hasn't really said or done anything. Most of his posts give the sense that he is unwilling to contribute.
I feel like a broken record tbh but PLEASE share with us your reads.
--------
LtLongshot: I've already made my stance on Longshot pretty clear. I won't be adding to it right now.
--------
JonCheee: I'm going through each post since day 1 and this is the first post that isn't just a shitpost/random vote.
The first post that mentioned game setup. Seemed to go largely ignored but Bijou's similar post sparked a lot of discussion? Something about this post is off to me as well. Seems kinda like Insie dropping hammerer out of nowhere. I wonder why nobody picked up on this post really except dean on p4. Seems like way more of a deal was made about Bijou's posts.
Hmmmmm
I still really don't like Jon's vote on Blaze, for conflicting reasons too. Part of me thinks it was a cheap vote on an easy lynchee and the other part of me thinks it was a subtle prompt from Jon to Blaze to be more active and simultaneously distance each other. I'm almost definitely overthinking this but yeah.
His p6 analysis was pretty weak, didn't really commit to making any calls on anyone. Hasn't made another similar post since so I'm curious what he thinks now.
Jon chucked some deserved shade on laggy that nobody really took much notice of unfortunately.
This is the next post that caught my eye.
I don't really feel like Jon was pushing as much as he claimed he was? He certainly did prod laggy but he didn't even vote for him or push it very far beyond one post.
--------
MrL: Great work innocent child. As our only confirmed townie, you need to be smart about what you say and do from here on out. I'd really appreciate it if you posted some more "Brutal reads" that you're known for. So far your only read wildly missed the mark but I'd appreciate some more contribution from you nonetheless. Keep at it, Ben.
--------
Windkeeper: I'll let dean focus on this guy, I'm tired after writing all of this other shit and I just don't know what to think about him at this stage. I was so sure he was townie but now I don't know. The dean evidence is quite compelling but I'm going to focus on pressuring others at this stage.
--------
As a final thing, I'm going to probably look at JEANS and Ghost as well to see if I can notice anything suss or enlightening about either of their postings.
I hope this isn't too much of a wall for everyone to tackle!
:*
04/01/2019 14:35:33
--------
Aerodrome: Voted 8 different times LOL. I guess he's being consistent. I've already talked a bit about why I think he's suss but let's look at some of his posting again anyways…
Rereading his posts he hasn't contributed much besides providing some info about game setup. He paid almost no attention to anyone who was suss of him and didn't respond to anyone. He was very, very adamant JEANS was maf but never really explained why. Just said "I luv bandwagons" a lot. Made a lot of posts without really saying anything. Good player that is definitely capable of more. What are your reads atm, Aero? You haven't provided any thus far.
--------
Asa: Incredibly aggressive towards JEANS but I think the tension between those two explains at least some of that. I honestly can't say that anyone looks too suss for lynching JEANS because a lot of the analysis posts of JEANS made him look very suss but I honestly think once he claimed people should have backed off. There isn't much else to look at from asa really. He didn't make too much noise before pushing hard for a JEANS lynch and I disagree with his thoughts on Bijou being scummy. There's one thing I do think looks a bit dodgy though:
asa said:
I'll call them out now, so that when you flip scum, I'll look like a god.
Reeks of arrogance. I wonder where you stand now given that JEANS flipped town.
--------
BattleDolphin:
BattleDolphin said:
Why is windkeeper so good at looking like a townie lmaooo
This post is just so weird. I know it looked like I was sucking up to windkeeper early on too but idk, I just didn't do it in this way? Maybe I did lol. Anyways…
BattleDolphin said:
Idk his defences seem pretty typical of him so idk what to say about that
Like I don't necessarily think he's Mafia but I also don't think he's town like idk
This is very wishy-washy language. Not committing to reading JEANS at all. Seems kinda like he's avoiding the burden of a read.
BattleDolphin said:
I feel like JonCheee is playing a bit weird/different to usual? He's accused like half the game and then there's never any discussion (except him voting for blaze), and then he just moves on to the next one?
He also totally ignored the big discussion with Dean and co. which is kinda odd imo
Soft call out on JonCheee, doesn't commit to the vote. Don't really agree with what he's said either, I think Jon is suss for different reasons. I don't think he accused half the game at all. I also think the majority of players ignored the dean vs. Maribro discussion or at the very least only acknowledged it. Nobody besides Bijou really got involved in it.
Dunno what to think of BD overall. He's defo on my suss radar though.
--------
Bijou: I think given what happened in the last day phase, it's pretty clear to me Bijou is town. I don't think mafia would want to rush to defend people as obviously suss as JEANS unless they were of the same alignment. I just can't see it being an optimal play for Scummy Bijou to defend JEANS and discuss with JEANS as much as he did. Giving all that information away isn't an optimal play for mafia. Maybe it's a wifom moment but I just can't see Bijou being scum at this stage.
--------
Blaze: Hasn't contributed enough. A suspicious lack of posts too, may just be taking a new approach to mafia given the discussions he's had with people about the game. I do think overall I'm just getting clueless townie vibes from him though.
--------
Boozer: Has contributed very little and as such is difficult to analyse. I think he's giving me town vibes but boozer's weird posting style tends to look "friendlier" than is necessarily true. Would appreciate it if you posted some reads you have.
--------
dean: I'm gonna keep this brief but you're absolutely my strongest town read. I'm very confident that you're town this game.
--------
Extra: Obviously has also contributed little overall but at the very least, has been vocal about one read, which I kinda agree with. Had the wrong read on MrL though but at least none of us have to chase that path. Was also wrong about JEANS unfortunately. I think his posts have been earnest overall and is defo a town lean for me at this stage.
--------
Laggy: Has contributed fuck all to be honest, after a decent showing in the last game, I was expecting more from him. It isn't that he's been… bad per se. It's just like Boozer, MrL, Aero (to a lesser extent) and Blaze, he hasn't really said or done anything. Most of his posts give the sense that he is unwilling to contribute.
ThatLaggyPerson said:
idk what to say though, everyone else has said my thoughts at this point
ThatLaggyPerson said:
im not gonna go any deeper on this, just my two cents.
I feel like a broken record tbh but PLEASE share with us your reads.
--------
LtLongshot: I've already made my stance on Longshot pretty clear. I won't be adding to it right now.
--------
JonCheee: I'm going through each post since day 1 and this is the first post that isn't just a shitpost/random vote.
JonCheee said:
wow its started woohoo. 2 mafia factions probably means lots of mafia right? assuming 3-4 per faction or is that too big of an assumption cos that would be 6-8 mafia in a 16 person game. thats almost/is half the game
The first post that mentioned game setup. Seemed to go largely ignored but Bijou's similar post sparked a lot of discussion? Something about this post is off to me as well. Seems kinda like Insie dropping hammerer out of nowhere. I wonder why nobody picked up on this post really except dean on p4. Seems like way more of a deal was made about Bijou's posts.
JonCheee said:
i voted for blaze cos he didnt say anything yet at the time. i just wanted a reaction from him if anything.
Hmmmmm
I still really don't like Jon's vote on Blaze, for conflicting reasons too. Part of me thinks it was a cheap vote on an easy lynchee and the other part of me thinks it was a subtle prompt from Jon to Blaze to be more active and simultaneously distance each other. I'm almost definitely overthinking this but yeah.
His p6 analysis was pretty weak, didn't really commit to making any calls on anyone. Hasn't made another similar post since so I'm curious what he thinks now.
Jon chucked some deserved shade on laggy that nobody really took much notice of unfortunately.
This is the next post that caught my eye.
JonCheee said:
by "to usual" are you comparing it to the 3 year old mafia game and the ultimate game? i dont remember anything from that fire emblem game (other than i won hee hee) so you should honestly not try metagame (is this the right term?) like that.
in the ultimate game i wanted to play back and just see what other people did but there were a lot of cases where i felt nothing was happening and it was kinda boring tbh, so this game i want to try make some plays and try get things going.
its day one, is it that bad that i'm trying to get information to help us?
I don't really feel like Jon was pushing as much as he claimed he was? He certainly did prod laggy but he didn't even vote for him or push it very far beyond one post.
--------
MrL: Great work innocent child. As our only confirmed townie, you need to be smart about what you say and do from here on out. I'd really appreciate it if you posted some more "Brutal reads" that you're known for. So far your only read wildly missed the mark but I'd appreciate some more contribution from you nonetheless. Keep at it, Ben.
--------
Windkeeper: I'll let dean focus on this guy, I'm tired after writing all of this other shit and I just don't know what to think about him at this stage. I was so sure he was townie but now I don't know. The dean evidence is quite compelling but I'm going to focus on pressuring others at this stage.
--------
As a final thing, I'm going to probably look at JEANS and Ghost as well to see if I can notice anything suss or enlightening about either of their postings.
I hope this isn't too much of a wall for everyone to tackle!
:*
04/01/2019 14:35:33
I'll post my reads later I'm busy grieving over the loss of katamari I miss morning chats with invisi
04/01/2019 22:41:33
04/01/2019 22:41:33
I miss them too Aero, mornings are so boring this game lol. We could always just flame everyone while they're not around.
04/01/2019 22:50:02
04/01/2019 22:50:02
I'm here OK I just take a long time to write my posts. Man I can't begrudge people for not posting yesterday but 48 hours in I'd wish we'd heard from asa or Windkeeper0 at some point today.
04/01/2019 23:12:20
04/01/2019 23:12:20
By the way, I've been DMing anyone who gets a considerable amount of votes against their name. Partly because I was annoyed at what happened to me last game lol, but mostly just to keep the game moving. I had to poke JEANS several times during Day 1 lol. So, feel free to wagon someone if you want them to talk I guess?
04/01/2019 23:24:12
04/01/2019 23:24:12
Invisi said:Excellent; an excuse to vote for Ben Gold.
By the way, I've been DMing anyone who gets a considerable amount of votes against their name. Partly because I was annoyed at what happened to me last game lol, but mostly just to keep the game moving. I had to poke JEANS several times during Day 1 lol. So, feel free to wagon someone if you want them to talk I guess?
04/01/2019 23:40:02
i am having a lazy morning and so in the spirit of that lazy morning im just gonna copy paste the stuff i had down in my word doc that i didnt get to post before day 1 ended thanks to a certain monsieur L
these are mostly just not fleshed out thoughts to give ppl an idea of what im thinking, with some annotations added where certain stuff happened (i havent really updated it since day 1 cos ive been busy).
SUS PLAYERS:
LtLongshot – super sus 'analysis' post after being voted for – 'its fine if you think im maf' – literally scummiest person on the planet – push day 2?? update: still sus but hes been more active recently which i think is a better sign towards him potentially not being scum. but yes i hate longshot this game fight me
Boozer – playing under the radar not necessarily doing anything wrong but get similar vibes as to when he was third party in ulti mafia.
Asa – weird ass roleclaim early not necessarily suspicious but played super far back and took a long time to make posts afterwards – was apparently just 'busy'. Still swinging hard at jeans and fighting with bijou a lot - wasn't really defended much by anyone
Jeans – lots of small slipups, not 100% convinced yet – being called out by everyone = bad sign but might be because of difficult to defend mistakes. Votes on him = JEANS (7): Asa, Boozer, Aerodrome, Maribro, Ghost, Windkeeper, JonCheee – would mafia go after own members when there's two different teams?? seems unlikely on day 1 update: was obviously town. not too cut that i misread this one, granted he was a powerful role, but there was still only 1 night death last night????
Aerodrome – the usual, can't sleep on him though – he knows that everyone expects him to play like this and so can get away with a lot more. Voted for like 5 different people, lots of ppl have been antagonistic towards him too but it's not above maf to stage stuff
Mr L – been very passive + soft claimed - “my role is more useful later on in the game don't lynch me” - everyones role is more useful later in the game dumb ass update: is town lol
potential town??
Blaze – has been pretty useless – maybe lurking mafia but get the feeling he would be trying harder – could be told by his team to not talk much. Might b a good role and quiet bc of that
Dean – smart player – feels different from game when he was maf. Doesnt let up on pressure, keeps attacking – could just be trying to scumhunt so aggressively because he's on scum side. Keep an eye on
Bijou – very active – very openly defending a lot of people – seems too risky for him to be outwardly maf – staunch maribro, jeans defender – was on the asa train but eventually unvoted, doesnt seem to be aggro on anyone else. Thinks longshot is town??? Revise after first lynch update: leaning towards town
unsure
Laggy – been quiet – can't tell if not very helpful town or scum – could be sleeper pick
Windkeeper – doesnt talk when mason
dean pointed out he's focused on jeans hard – good pick up on the 'thought light was town' tho – doesn't necessarily exonerate him. revise after first lynch
Maribro – been on the defensive for like the whole game, says that he's playing differently – bijou trusts him, dean doesn't – probably more inclined to believe he's townie but kinda strange that bijou stepped in to defend him so hard??? – go through and analyze interactions between him and dean zzzzzzzzfdsfdssdfsdf update: still havent gone over it bc fuck that conversation, i appreciate the most recent post he made tho
need to go over: ghost jonchee bd update: ghost was maf
04/02/2019 01:22:47
these are mostly just not fleshed out thoughts to give ppl an idea of what im thinking, with some annotations added where certain stuff happened (i havent really updated it since day 1 cos ive been busy).
SUS PLAYERS:
LtLongshot – super sus 'analysis' post after being voted for – 'its fine if you think im maf' – literally scummiest person on the planet – push day 2?? update: still sus but hes been more active recently which i think is a better sign towards him potentially not being scum. but yes i hate longshot this game fight me
Boozer – playing under the radar not necessarily doing anything wrong but get similar vibes as to when he was third party in ulti mafia.
Asa – weird ass roleclaim early not necessarily suspicious but played super far back and took a long time to make posts afterwards – was apparently just 'busy'. Still swinging hard at jeans and fighting with bijou a lot - wasn't really defended much by anyone
Jeans – lots of small slipups, not 100% convinced yet – being called out by everyone = bad sign but might be because of difficult to defend mistakes. Votes on him = JEANS (7): Asa, Boozer, Aerodrome, Maribro, Ghost, Windkeeper, JonCheee – would mafia go after own members when there's two different teams?? seems unlikely on day 1 update: was obviously town. not too cut that i misread this one, granted he was a powerful role, but there was still only 1 night death last night????
Aerodrome – the usual, can't sleep on him though – he knows that everyone expects him to play like this and so can get away with a lot more. Voted for like 5 different people, lots of ppl have been antagonistic towards him too but it's not above maf to stage stuff
Mr L – been very passive + soft claimed - “my role is more useful later on in the game don't lynch me” - everyones role is more useful later in the game dumb ass update: is town lol
potential town??
Blaze – has been pretty useless – maybe lurking mafia but get the feeling he would be trying harder – could be told by his team to not talk much. Might b a good role and quiet bc of that
Dean – smart player – feels different from game when he was maf. Doesnt let up on pressure, keeps attacking – could just be trying to scumhunt so aggressively because he's on scum side. Keep an eye on
Bijou – very active – very openly defending a lot of people – seems too risky for him to be outwardly maf – staunch maribro, jeans defender – was on the asa train but eventually unvoted, doesnt seem to be aggro on anyone else. Thinks longshot is town??? Revise after first lynch update: leaning towards town
unsure
Laggy – been quiet – can't tell if not very helpful town or scum – could be sleeper pick
Windkeeper – doesnt talk when mason
dean pointed out he's focused on jeans hard – good pick up on the 'thought light was town' tho – doesn't necessarily exonerate him. revise after first lynch
Maribro – been on the defensive for like the whole game, says that he's playing differently – bijou trusts him, dean doesn't – probably more inclined to believe he's townie but kinda strange that bijou stepped in to defend him so hard??? – go through and analyze interactions between him and dean zzzzzzzzfdsfdssdfsdf update: still havent gone over it bc fuck that conversation, i appreciate the most recent post he made tho
need to go over: ghost jonchee bd update: ghost was maf
04/02/2019 01:22:47
Finally we can read walls of text again
Yet you look like a fool Vote: ASA
Your posts at the end of day 1 came off looking super scum. And this callout was fucking dumb as shit lmao.
04/02/2019 01:57:50
asa said:
I'll call them out now, so that when you flip scum, I'll look like a god.
Yet you look like a fool Vote: ASA
Your posts at the end of day 1 came off looking super scum. And this callout was fucking dumb as shit lmao.
04/02/2019 01:57:50
@Dean I appreciate the effort you're taking to start new discussions on players that haven't been pulled up on things, but is there any particular reason you've focused on Aero and Wind while mostly ignoring Asa?
He's the most suss of the three in my opinion and unlike Aero / Wind was actually active while Jeans was L-1 and didn't do anything to stop it.
For a guy who is really confident in his reads he hasn't made any correct ones so far.
Yeah I'm leaning town on Longshot at the moment purely for the reason that he sided with me early when Asa / Aero were voting me and the fact he didn't vote Jeans when he was L-1. He was active around the time he was lynched. Seemed to me like he was actually reading the situation well from a town point of view by not voting.
04/02/2019 02:32:53
He's the most suss of the three in my opinion and unlike Aero / Wind was actually active while Jeans was L-1 and didn't do anything to stop it.
For a guy who is really confident in his reads he hasn't made any correct ones so far.
Extra said:
Bijou – very active – very openly defending a lot of people – seems too risky for him to be outwardly maf – staunch maribro, jeans defender – was on the asa train but eventually unvoted, doesnt seem to be aggro on anyone else. Thinks longshot is town??? Revise after first lynch update: leaning towards town
Yeah I'm leaning town on Longshot at the moment purely for the reason that he sided with me early when Asa / Aero were voting me and the fact he didn't vote Jeans when he was L-1. He was active around the time he was lynched. Seemed to me like he was actually reading the situation well from a town point of view by not voting.
04/02/2019 02:32:53
I didn't feel a huge need to go into asa because I knew that others would (or had) and he had like as much content as Aerodrome and Windkeeper0 combined so analysing that would have made my post even bigger.
He's like 3rd on my list of scummies and I think he has a reasonable chance of flipping scum so I don't really want to come across as defending him but from my perspective Aerodrome and Windkeeper0 just came across as a lot more opportunistic... and in my mind that seems more mafia-esque behaviour.
It's kind of like... I thought that Windkeeper0 was the BEST option but all of Windkeeper0 / asa / Aerodrome are good options today.
Like Aerodrome posted that his gut feeling said that JEANS was maf, then he disappeared for two days and when he came back flopped onto BattleDolphin after I pointed out some oddities in BattleDolphin / Windkeeper0 / Maribro behaviour. So did his gut feel suddenly stop being that JEANS was mafia?
If nothing else, asa's actions have been consistent (consistently WRONG, but consistent); he didn't move his vote off JEANS after he placed it, prodded him with questions a couple of times and made an attempt at an analysis post on JEANS (before the light = town thing was fully brought to the fore).
Windkeeper0 WAS active when JEANS was at L-1 btw - or at least close to it - he made a post egging the JEANS wagon on about 20 minutes after Maribro took his vote off JEANS (so L-2), and I'm a little skeptical that he wouldn't have checked the thread at all again that night.
It would also be a little hypocritical of me to bug him about being active that night and not unvoting because the same applies to me.
Looking back at this I actually think Aerodrome's behaviour looks the worst, but Windkeeper's seems like the most out-of-place / out-of-character.
But if Invisi's going to be prodding players that get a lot of votes, three votes on asa is more than two on Windkeeper0!
VOTE: asa
04/02/2019 03:46:43
He's like 3rd on my list of scummies and I think he has a reasonable chance of flipping scum so I don't really want to come across as defending him but from my perspective Aerodrome and Windkeeper0 just came across as a lot more opportunistic... and in my mind that seems more mafia-esque behaviour.
It's kind of like... I thought that Windkeeper0 was the BEST option but all of Windkeeper0 / asa / Aerodrome are good options today.
Like Aerodrome posted that his gut feeling said that JEANS was maf, then he disappeared for two days and when he came back flopped onto BattleDolphin after I pointed out some oddities in BattleDolphin / Windkeeper0 / Maribro behaviour. So did his gut feel suddenly stop being that JEANS was mafia?
If nothing else, asa's actions have been consistent (consistently WRONG, but consistent); he didn't move his vote off JEANS after he placed it, prodded him with questions a couple of times and made an attempt at an analysis post on JEANS (before the light = town thing was fully brought to the fore).
Windkeeper0 WAS active when JEANS was at L-1 btw - or at least close to it - he made a post egging the JEANS wagon on about 20 minutes after Maribro took his vote off JEANS (so L-2), and I'm a little skeptical that he wouldn't have checked the thread at all again that night.
It would also be a little hypocritical of me to bug him about being active that night and not unvoting because the same applies to me.
Looking back at this I actually think Aerodrome's behaviour looks the worst, but Windkeeper's seems like the most out-of-place / out-of-character.
But if Invisi's going to be prodding players that get a lot of votes, three votes on asa is more than two on Windkeeper0!
VOTE: asa
04/02/2019 03:46:43
my (wall) thoughts:
unsure list:
Battledolphin, Boozer, Extra, asa
I feel like battledolphin is just posting a lot of fluff and not really adding to the discussion. not entirely flying under the radar but i get the feeling he's trying to distance himself while "contributing". unsure if its because hes suss or not.
Boozer is literally doing nothing, i cant read that. since theres no 3rd parties, i'm inclined to say hes suss but honestly he could jsut be uninterested, wouldnt put it past him.
Extra's posting habits have been very irregular but hes got thoughts at least to play. i'm leaning town on him, i think he's being helpful for what hes written.
asa is an enigma, i feel like he's just an idiot and has gained a lot of attention from being so. i didnt get to see how he played much in the ulti game since he subbed in late. unsure if hes actually suss or an accidentally wrong townie in regards to jeans. his read on bijou was also very optimistic and in hindsight looks like an idiot (again).
town lean
Maribro, Bijou, dean, MrL (lol)
I honestly think all 3 of the long posters are town. as far as marioboros play is, it doesnt seem suss to me. after bijous defense of jeans, its pretty clear hes probably town, unless its a 3000IQ play to defend a townie to the end. dean is dean. he's such a strong player and hes attacking people smartly.
suss reads
laggy, ltlongshot, aerodome
like i said before, i'm always suss of aero's play. flinging so many votes around can be consistent but consistent doesnt always mean good. obviously a results biased analysis but many things aero has said about jeans makes him look real suss, and i've honestly leaned on him being maf rn.
for ltlongshot, most people have already described what i find suss about his play, not really sure how much i can add to this.
i called laggy out in day one and nothing happened, so its another call out and i'm actually going to vote: laggy this time. last time i wanted to keep my vote on mrL as i thought he was pretty suss but evidently not. laggy is withholding his thoughts and i believe its because he doesnt want to slip up.
ive realised i've missed out on blaze and windkeeper but i have no opinion of them yet zzz
prays for formatting again
error 500
04/02/2019 08:22:27
unsure list:
Battledolphin, Boozer, Extra, asa
I feel like battledolphin is just posting a lot of fluff and not really adding to the discussion. not entirely flying under the radar but i get the feeling he's trying to distance himself while "contributing". unsure if its because hes suss or not.
Boozer is literally doing nothing, i cant read that. since theres no 3rd parties, i'm inclined to say hes suss but honestly he could jsut be uninterested, wouldnt put it past him.
Extra's posting habits have been very irregular but hes got thoughts at least to play. i'm leaning town on him, i think he's being helpful for what hes written.
asa is an enigma, i feel like he's just an idiot and has gained a lot of attention from being so. i didnt get to see how he played much in the ulti game since he subbed in late. unsure if hes actually suss or an accidentally wrong townie in regards to jeans. his read on bijou was also very optimistic and in hindsight looks like an idiot (again).
town lean
Maribro, Bijou, dean, MrL (lol)
I honestly think all 3 of the long posters are town. as far as marioboros play is, it doesnt seem suss to me. after bijous defense of jeans, its pretty clear hes probably town, unless its a 3000IQ play to defend a townie to the end. dean is dean. he's such a strong player and hes attacking people smartly.
suss reads
laggy, ltlongshot, aerodome
like i said before, i'm always suss of aero's play. flinging so many votes around can be consistent but consistent doesnt always mean good. obviously a results biased analysis but many things aero has said about jeans makes him look real suss, and i've honestly leaned on him being maf rn.
for ltlongshot, most people have already described what i find suss about his play, not really sure how much i can add to this.
i called laggy out in day one and nothing happened, so its another call out and i'm actually going to vote: laggy this time. last time i wanted to keep my vote on mrL as i thought he was pretty suss but evidently not. laggy is withholding his thoughts and i believe its because he doesnt want to slip up.
ive realised i've missed out on blaze and windkeeper but i have no opinion of them yet zzz
prays for formatting again
error 500
04/02/2019 08:22:27
Sorry I was getting an error message on Sunday so I couldn't get on. Yesterday I could get on started reading day 2 but the boxes were giving me a headache so I decided to wait until today. I've been having the same error message all day today but I've finally been able to get on. I've caught up with everything but now my internet is stuffing up so let's hope this actually gets through.
I've still got the post that I didn't include earlier on my laptop but since I'm moving tomorrow and I would have to add a couple of things anyway I can't really get it up tonight (laptop packed up and I have to be up at 6). I'll try my best to get it up by tomorrow night.
04/02/2019 10:18:39
I've still got the post that I didn't include earlier on my laptop but since I'm moving tomorrow and I would have to add a couple of things anyway I can't really get it up tonight (laptop packed up and I have to be up at 6). I'll try my best to get it up by tomorrow night.
04/02/2019 10:18:39
Yes apparently we're being DDOS'd by google or something due to the April Fools thing. Makes it kinda hard to play mafia when the page only works half the time.
04/02/2019 10:51:08
04/02/2019 10:51:08
I forgot to post tonight cos I was doing frame data and etc I'll do it tomorrow I promise.
04/02/2019 14:10:27
04/02/2019 14:10:27
Aerodrome said:
I forgot to post tonight cos I was doing frame data and etc I'll do it tomorrow I promise.
Do you pinky promise?
04/02/2019 20:43:24
Error 500 btw
04/02/2019 23:57:41
04/02/2019 23:57:41
With the errors we've seen over the past few days and a number of people away for EG4 in the coming week, I would be happy to entertain an extension in the deadline, but let's wait and see next week as to whether it's needed.
04/03/2019 00:01:37
04/03/2019 00:01:37
Is the katamari gone
It is
The evil is defeated
04/03/2019 00:17:19
It is
The evil is defeated
04/03/2019 00:17:19