ghost didn't get lynched, he was shot n1
04/19/2019 03:26:15
Bijou said:
JEANS was confirmed town lol. There is no reason to doubt he was lying about it.
Er, as in there is no reason to suspect he was lying rather.
04/19/2019 03:26:37
Bijou said:
asa said:
my role dies if it succeeds
the wording also does not have any extra fluff for as to why it fails if 2 people both try kill my target, it clearly states from one kill
You say this as if you're still suspicious of JEANS claiming his doctor role specified that it failed if two factions target his choice.
JEANS was confirmed town lol. There is no reason to doubt he was lying about it.
no, I'm saying this is why I was originally suspicious about the whole ordeal over wording
04/19/2019 03:26:57
Bijou said:Ngl this is a pretty big gottem
asa said:
my role dies if it succeeds
the wording also does not have any extra fluff for as to why it fails if 2 people both try kill my target, it clearly states from one kill
You say this as if you're still suspicious of JEANS claiming his doctor role specified that it failed if two factions target his choice.
JEANS was confirmed town lol. There is no reason to doubt he was lying about it.
04/19/2019 03:27:11
Oh right yeah This makes sense I'm now less dumb
04/19/2019 03:28:08
04/19/2019 03:28:08
asa said:
Bijou said:
asa said:
my role dies if it succeeds
the wording also does not have any extra fluff for as to why it fails if 2 people both try kill my target, it clearly states from one kill
You say this as if you're still suspicious of JEANS claiming his doctor role specified that it failed if two factions target his choice.
JEANS was confirmed town lol. There is no reason to doubt he was lying about it.
no, I'm saying this is why I was originally suspicious about the whole ordeal over wording
Okay, that makes sense.
04/19/2019 03:28:26
Bijou said:I have zero way to know if anyone targeted me last night.
Okay seems fair unless Dean can say otherwise.
Aero why did you target Windkeeper0 instead of Shane, considering that you were confident that Shane was town as soon as he abstained from the JEANS lynch?
Sorry for lurking but this thread is such a mess I don't know what to post most of the time.
04/19/2019 03:28:58
this is just a mess lmao
BTW we got 30 minutes
04/19/2019 03:31:02
BTW we got 30 minutes
04/19/2019 03:31:02
I am 100% sure aero is lying
He went aggressively after me as the easy lynch of today, mostly hopping on the back of bijou's wagon
His maniuplative language was alarming
the speed of my current wagon (yeah I know it's deadline, but the speed at which it returned to me, rather than on one of the other focuses of suspicion such as laggy alarmed me
especially after aero could point out no holes in my defense
04/19/2019 03:31:28
He went aggressively after me as the easy lynch of today, mostly hopping on the back of bijou's wagon
His maniuplative language was alarming
the speed of my current wagon (yeah I know it's deadline, but the speed at which it returned to me, rather than on one of the other focuses of suspicion such as laggy alarmed me
especially after aero could point out no holes in my defense
04/19/2019 03:31:28
asa said:
Bijou said:Hmm? Why not? Also, where did you get vote from btw?
The doctor not being able to save someone if both factions vote them is a really interesting mechanic and I don't believe JEANS could have made this up on his own.BattleDolphin said:
I wanna say it's actually super common that if a doc target gets double shot they still die?
Can someone else with knowledge confirm
Ehh yeah I was gonna save this but w/e
But I'm not sure there would be anything that would line up like that, having a power that fails if both factions do something to it seems like it could only be a town power.He said kill didn't he?
and the 'a' that light and dark could both do is kill someone I heal
It's normal for a doctor to only be able to protect against 1 kill per night.
If it's just a regular doctor by the sounds of it, I feel like there's zero chance that it would be explicitly stated that the "heal" would fail if they were shot by 2 kills in one night.
It Lines up with what he was saying day 1 about JEAN's Power actually
UNVOTE
04/19/2019 03:32:38
dean said:I just thought Windkeeper was more likely to die at night than Shane.
Bijou said:I have zero way to know if anyone targeted me last night.
Okay seems fair unless Dean can say otherwise.
Aero why did you target Windkeeper0 instead of Shane, considering that you were confident that Shane was town as soon as he abstained from the JEANS lynch?
Sorry for lurking but this thread is such a mess I don't know what to post most of the time.
04/19/2019 03:33:38
Vote: Aero
I have a strange feeling he might be trying to sac himself to get rid of a role. His talk about Mafia doctors also makes me think that if he is mafia there might be a doctor to protect him from night kills making his fake claim make us waste time.
04/19/2019 03:36:03
I have a strange feeling he might be trying to sac himself to get rid of a role. His talk about Mafia doctors also makes me think that if he is mafia there might be a doctor to protect him from night kills making his fake claim make us waste time.
04/19/2019 03:36:03
asa said:
I am 100% sure aero is lying
He went aggressively after me as the easy lynch of today, mostly hopping on the back of bijou's wagon
His maniuplative language was alarming
the speed of my current wagon (yeah I know it's deadline, but the speed at which it returned to me, rather than on one of the other focuses of suspicion such as laggy alarmed me
especially after aero could point out no holes in my defense
Well obviously if you know that you're a bodyguard and Aero is claiming it as a counter to your claim then it should be pretty obvious to you that he's lying.
The way you're explaining it makes it kind of sound like you're trying to justify to yourself why he's lying rather than it being something you should just know since you're the only one who knows what your real role is.
Worst case scenario if Aero is lying is that we mislynch you and then we'll know to lynch Aero tomorrow. There was no real reason for him to make a fake claim this late in the day when you were the prime lynch target anyway.
04/19/2019 03:36:07
who's shane? bijou?
04/19/2019 03:36:12
04/19/2019 03:36:12
asa said:
who's shane? bijou?
ye
04/19/2019 03:37:00
because I see that aero is lying 100%
it's anti-town if you allow a confirmed town (yourself) to get lynched so of course I'm going to try my hardest to not get lynched to me, I feel like he's just trying to bomb me out, trade 1 for 1, but at least be able to take me out first, because he's been unsuccessful so far to get me lynched, after 2 days
does this mean my reads are correct or incorrect and he's throwing wifom at me
04/19/2019 03:42:41
it's anti-town if you allow a confirmed town (yourself) to get lynched so of course I'm going to try my hardest to not get lynched to me, I feel like he's just trying to bomb me out, trade 1 for 1, but at least be able to take me out first, because he's been unsuccessful so far to get me lynched, after 2 days
does this mean my reads are correct or incorrect and he's throwing wifom at me
04/19/2019 03:42:41
We've got 20 mins left so do people want to lynch Aero or Asa?
I'm fine with either so long as it gives us information.
04/19/2019 03:43:15
I'm fine with either so long as it gives us information.
04/19/2019 03:43:15
Aerodrome said:As a town bodyguard you need to be VERY certain that the player you're targeting is town because protecting a mafioso from getting shot by the opposing team and dying because of it is an absurd way to die, and it seems like you've claimed to have protected someone that you're not too sure about.
I just thought Windkeeper was more likely to die at night than Shane.
Out of Aerodrome and asa... I think Aerodrome's the more likely to be mafia. At the very least his claims make less sense.
VOTE: Aerodrome
04/19/2019 03:45:17
Bijou said:
We've got 20 mins left so do people want to lynch Aero or Asa?
I'm fine with either so long as it gives us information.
To me it feels like Aero has a few more holes in his claim than ASA. ASA targeted a higher value target compared to Aero IMHO. And the timing makes me think he could be trading.
04/19/2019 03:45:35
i've been pretty suss on aero for a while and i didnt really like the counter claim.
vote: aero
04/19/2019 03:46:03
vote: aero
04/19/2019 03:46:03
I am down to lynch either, so aero?
04/19/2019 03:48:24
04/19/2019 03:48:24
My emotional side wants to kill Asa, but my logical side suggests his reasoning makes sense in context for the way he has been playing. If Aero is town then Asa is dead tomorrow anyway so whatever. Will join whichever train gets the most traction.
04/19/2019 03:48:37
04/19/2019 03:48:37
I don't see why aero would defend me last night and then vote for me the following day saying that he believed I was mafia. Sorry I haven't been on yet i just caught up
04/19/2019 03:49:48
04/19/2019 03:49:48
unvote
will think it over for like 5 mins sorry guys
04/19/2019 03:49:57
will think it over for like 5 mins sorry guys
04/19/2019 03:49:57
Quite a few potential light mafias switching to aero vote :thinking:
I dont think aero would be dumb enough to try and counter claim a scenario that happened to him last game, surely he'd know the risk of it backfiring would be too great considering no one was really considering switching off asa until he did
Im gonna stay on asa but either way tomorrows lynch is basically set to be the other candidate
04/19/2019 03:50:07
I dont think aero would be dumb enough to try and counter claim a scenario that happened to him last game, surely he'd know the risk of it backfiring would be too great considering no one was really considering switching off asa until he did
Im gonna stay on asa but either way tomorrows lynch is basically set to be the other candidate
04/19/2019 03:50:07