It annoys me that we're 72 hours into the day and we have two players that haven't posted at all and seven that haven't posted anything relevant and I can't really blame people because between server issues and that kalamari rubbish on Monday trying to use this website has been awful.
It seems to be a little better now.
Come friends, let us check to see if asa's still alive by voting for him.
I'm bored and don't have heaps to add since yesterday so I would throw in my thoughts on LtLongshot since that seems to be the main pressure / votetrain rivaling what I want (Aerodrome / Windkeeper0) but I know people don't like it when I kind-of defend other players.
04/03/2019 00:37:38
dean said:I did a general announcement that EG4 was a thing but Asa in particular asked me to mention that he had trouble with the thread over the past few days (as we all did) and he is leaving for EG4 today until Monday night and will likely be unable to post until Tuesday.
Come friends, let us check to see if asa's still alive by voting for him.
04/03/2019 00:53:39
I was definitely using my morning at work productively...
Now that the site has loaded for the first time all week, I'll just leave this here
Also yes, EG4.
04/03/2019 01:19:49
Now that the site has loaded for the first time all week, I'll just leave this here
Also yes, EG4.
04/03/2019 01:19:49
Tuesday as in six days from now? Ew. Gong was a mistake.
Can I get confirmation on who's going to Gong?
04/03/2019 01:42:20
Can I get confirmation on who's going to Gong?
04/03/2019 01:42:20
Server shitting itself again, I give up.
See you all Tuesday
04/03/2019 01:47:20
See you all Tuesday
04/03/2019 01:47:20
Be, Asa, and Me are traveling to gong via car. We leaving thrusday. So yeah probably wont be much activity from us until Monday/Tuesday.
04/03/2019 02:14:39
04/03/2019 02:14:39
Not sure if "Be" is a typo of "Ben" or a typo of "Bd".
VOTE: Windkeeper0
May as well focus on the players that ARE going to be here for the rest of the week and move on to the Queenslanders next week.
04/03/2019 04:11:06
VOTE: Windkeeper0
May as well focus on the players that ARE going to be here for the rest of the week and move on to the Queenslanders next week.
04/03/2019 04:11:06
Its BD lmao
04/03/2019 05:02:48
04/03/2019 05:02:48
im going to gong, ghost is going to supernova nintendo thing same weekend, i think mr L is going to gong as well
i havent been able to get on the site all day up until now and im not 100% sure my post will go through. if asa legit cant really post til tuesday (i know typing on phone is annoying but it's still possible and probably necessary for the health of the game) then im not sure how to proceed.
04/03/2019 05:57:55
i havent been able to get on the site all day up until now and im not 100% sure my post will go through. if asa legit cant really post til tuesday (i know typing on phone is annoying but it's still possible and probably necessary for the health of the game) then im not sure how to proceed.
04/03/2019 05:57:55
ghost is dead you nerd
04/03/2019 06:06:12
04/03/2019 06:06:12
oh wow im retarded
04/03/2019 06:08:18
04/03/2019 06:08:18
Can I just say…
This is NOT contributing.
Blaze, Laggy, Boozer. You guys need to step it up.
Also where the FUCK is MrL. I get it, you're town. C O N T R I B U T E
I'm MAD
ALSO ALSO
Where is Aero's post??
vote: Aerodrome
04/03/2019 13:08:51
ThatLaggyPerson said:
ben gold with the 6 quintrillion iq play the innocent child so that he can prove nothing
Blaze said:
I was so scared when i was getting this Katamari thing i looked up what it was and it came up with Katamari Damacy please someone hel
Boozer said:
Is the katamari gone
It is
The evil is defeated
ThatLaggyPerson said:
katamari minigame will defeat light and dark, easy
This is NOT contributing.
Blaze, Laggy, Boozer. You guys need to step it up.
Also where the FUCK is MrL. I get it, you're town. C O N T R I B U T E
I'm MAD
ALSO ALSO
Where is Aero's post??
vote: Aerodrome
04/03/2019 13:08:51
My reads as promised.
Dunno:
Dean: Is scumhunting. I don't know if he's town or mafia but at this point I don't care either way since even if he is mafia he is still scumhunting. Although considering he was happy to lynch JEANS and is targeting me I'm wondering if he isn't as good at it as I originally thought he was.
JonCheee: No idea really.
BattleDolphin: Probably town but no clue otherwise.
Boozer: Isn't really contributing so idk, uninterested townie?
ThatLaggyPerson: Also isn't contributing, uninterested townie?
Windkeeper: Dean thinks he's mafia but I have no read on him really.
Town-lean:
Bijou: Abstained from the JEANS lynch, so I'm fairly confident he's town.
Extra: Didn't realize Ghost was dead and mafia, so I'm getting "youtube binge" vibes from him and think he's town.
Mr L: Idiot.
Maribro: See Bijou.
Mafia-lean:
Blaze: Isn't posting. I'm willing to bet he's mafia and trying to lay low.
Asa: Playing incredibly strangely, honestly my lynch pick for today but is he mafia or just dumb town, I can't tell.
LtLongshot: I put him here for the same reasons as Extra, plus he's extremely aggressive sometimes which is weird. Interestingly he didn't vote JEANS off when day almost was finished under the logic that JEANS would get targeted by a mafia faction, which is kinda strange (I think Maribro brought this up before). There's a number of reasons why I think it's scummy and that's mainly because the mafia don't have to kill JEANS at night, then JEANS still looks suspicious and we're back at square one. Unvote
04/03/2019 14:52:16
Dunno:
Dean: Is scumhunting. I don't know if he's town or mafia but at this point I don't care either way since even if he is mafia he is still scumhunting. Although considering he was happy to lynch JEANS and is targeting me I'm wondering if he isn't as good at it as I originally thought he was.
JonCheee: No idea really.
BattleDolphin: Probably town but no clue otherwise.
Boozer: Isn't really contributing so idk, uninterested townie?
ThatLaggyPerson: Also isn't contributing, uninterested townie?
Windkeeper: Dean thinks he's mafia but I have no read on him really.
Town-lean:
Bijou: Abstained from the JEANS lynch, so I'm fairly confident he's town.
Extra: Didn't realize Ghost was dead and mafia, so I'm getting "youtube binge" vibes from him and think he's town.
Mr L: Idiot.
Maribro: See Bijou.
Mafia-lean:
Blaze: Isn't posting. I'm willing to bet he's mafia and trying to lay low.
Asa: Playing incredibly strangely, honestly my lynch pick for today but is he mafia or just dumb town, I can't tell.
LtLongshot: I put him here for the same reasons as Extra, plus he's extremely aggressive sometimes which is weird. Interestingly he didn't vote JEANS off when day almost was finished under the logic that JEANS would get targeted by a mafia faction, which is kinda strange (I think Maribro brought this up before). There's a number of reasons why I think it's scummy and that's mainly because the mafia don't have to kill JEANS at night, then JEANS still looks suspicious and we're back at square one. Unvote
04/03/2019 14:52:16
I love the logic that boozer and laggy are uninterested townie but im written off as laylow mafia where im p sure ive tried harder than both of them so far :P. Its not encouraging to post when last game i get lynched for posting lots, then u say im scum for not posting much, most of my opinions are biased at this point based on what other people have said, and id just be repeating what othere have said. And when i tried to make a big contribution i was kinda told it was bad lmao. Ive said im trying my best, but i dont have anything to post regarding who i think is scum/town, everyone looks really neutral to me.
04/04/2019 00:17:38
04/04/2019 00:17:38
My phone data seems to be actually working so I'll get this up before it messes up again.
Sorry that I delayed this, I didn't realise how exhausted I was after the move and feel asleep on the floor while i was trying to stretch. I should also note that while I'm not getting the error message every time the internet isn't going to be working until Tuesday and the phone reception is pretty bad so checking the thread is kind of difficult at the moment. I can get on sometimes but it's luck of the draw if it will actually work at the moment.
I had a lot going on during the start of the game so I wasn't on as much as I would have liked. This meant I was a bit behind on the thread for most of day 1. I'll go over my reasoning for mentioning JEANS in each post:
Post 1
The opening post just mentioned JEANS because he confirmed what asa's removed post said.
Post 2
My thoughts on the situation at the start of the game as well as asking JEANS to confirm the reasons behind the situation.
Post 3
This was where I voted for JEANS initially, to explain my reasoning:
It was far too early to end day 1 so while I was suspicious of JEANS my intention wasn't to get him lynched but to try getting the conversation rolling. I was more so putting pressure on him so that he would answer the questions that he hadn't answered yet and to see if he slipped up while doing so. This is why I unvoted so easily.
L-4 was halfway to a lynch but it was still a while off so I thought it would be a good point to vote. It was highly unlikely that 4 people would vote to kill him before he had a chance to defend himself and even if they did they would essentially be outing themselves so there wasn't much risk.
I thought that JEANS was only mad at asa for the tier list which didn't seem to be true once JEANS said that asa had been rude to him in the dms and Bijou confirmed it. While I did know that JEANS tends to react strongly I wasn't sure if that was enough to warrant the response so I wanted confirmation on his reasoning. I definitely could have worded it better but I was trying to make sure that my vote still held weight to pressure him so saying it was a soft vote didn't seem like the best course of action.
The darkon post seemed off to me since it could have been him trying to distance himself from information that the mafia most likely had.
Post 4 and 5
I unvoted JEANS but didn't really have the time to explain my reasoning at the time so I did it in the following post. I kept it brief so that I could move on to other topics since the conversation had already ended but I didn't explain myself well enough since this post exists.
With JEANS and Bijou making me realise that I probably missed the majority of the disagreement JEANS strong response made more sense to me. While I still thought that JEANS could have been playing it up I thought it was less likely now and I thought the darkon post wasn't strong enough evidence against him at that point so I unvoted.
"I'm still not sure he's town but I don't think we have enough on him to warrant a lynch unless we don't find someone else." I missed the "don't" in the original post and left a note afterwards to correct it but I still could have worded this a lot better. Basically I was saying that I was more neutral on JEANS with a very slight scum lean and the second part was more so saying if we can't agree on anyone else to lynch not that he would be my number 1 pick.
I'll go into the second interaction if you want me too (it shouldn't take nearly as long this time as long as I can actually get on the site) but it looks like your main gripe is with the first interaction.
04/04/2019 00:43:14
Sorry that I delayed this, I didn't realise how exhausted I was after the move and feel asleep on the floor while i was trying to stretch. I should also note that while I'm not getting the error message every time the internet isn't going to be working until Tuesday and the phone reception is pretty bad so checking the thread is kind of difficult at the moment. I can get on sometimes but it's luck of the draw if it will actually work at the moment.
Dean said:
I realise I threw some shade at Windkeeper in an earlier post without really explaining why which was rude of me but from my perspective:
1. He's extremely fixated on JEANS - legit EVERY single one of his posts has brought him up. It's not as if we haven't had other things to talk about.
2. I kind of felt that his reasoning for jumping on the wagon was weak and felt opportunistic.
Exactly what kind of information did you hope to get out of JEANS at this point of time, considering that in your previous post you acknowledged that it was:
a) in character for JEANS to react strongly and
b) that you knew that he didn't like asa?
What did he post that elected you to unvote for him, considering that you still seem to think that he's the number one choice to lynch?
It just kind of felt at the time like opportunistic mafia looking for a cheap kill to me.
I had a lot going on during the start of the game so I wasn't on as much as I would have liked. This meant I was a bit behind on the thread for most of day 1. I'll go over my reasoning for mentioning JEANS in each post:
Post 1
The opening post just mentioned JEANS because he confirmed what asa's removed post said.
Post 2
My thoughts on the situation at the start of the game as well as asking JEANS to confirm the reasons behind the situation.
Post 3
This was where I voted for JEANS initially, to explain my reasoning:
It was far too early to end day 1 so while I was suspicious of JEANS my intention wasn't to get him lynched but to try getting the conversation rolling. I was more so putting pressure on him so that he would answer the questions that he hadn't answered yet and to see if he slipped up while doing so. This is why I unvoted so easily.
L-4 was halfway to a lynch but it was still a while off so I thought it would be a good point to vote. It was highly unlikely that 4 people would vote to kill him before he had a chance to defend himself and even if they did they would essentially be outing themselves so there wasn't much risk.
I thought that JEANS was only mad at asa for the tier list which didn't seem to be true once JEANS said that asa had been rude to him in the dms and Bijou confirmed it. While I did know that JEANS tends to react strongly I wasn't sure if that was enough to warrant the response so I wanted confirmation on his reasoning. I definitely could have worded it better but I was trying to make sure that my vote still held weight to pressure him so saying it was a soft vote didn't seem like the best course of action.
The darkon post seemed off to me since it could have been him trying to distance himself from information that the mafia most likely had.
Post 4 and 5
I unvoted JEANS but didn't really have the time to explain my reasoning at the time so I did it in the following post. I kept it brief so that I could move on to other topics since the conversation had already ended but I didn't explain myself well enough since this post exists.
With JEANS and Bijou making me realise that I probably missed the majority of the disagreement JEANS strong response made more sense to me. While I still thought that JEANS could have been playing it up I thought it was less likely now and I thought the darkon post wasn't strong enough evidence against him at that point so I unvoted.
"I'm still not sure he's town but I don't think we have enough on him to warrant a lynch unless we don't find someone else." I missed the "don't" in the original post and left a note afterwards to correct it but I still could have worded this a lot better. Basically I was saying that I was more neutral on JEANS with a very slight scum lean and the second part was more so saying if we can't agree on anyone else to lynch not that he would be my number 1 pick.
I'll go into the second interaction if you want me too (it shouldn't take nearly as long this time as long as I can actually get on the site) but it looks like your main gripe is with the first interaction.
04/04/2019 00:43:14
I sincerely hope that crayon never attempts anything for 1st April ever again.
So who isn't going away for Wollongong?
Bijou, Aerodrome, dean, JonCheee, Maribro, ThatLaggyPerson, Blaze, Boozer, Windkeeper0. May as well focus on these players for now.
OK about Longshot. I think I need a little help, can someone help walk Uncle Dean through what made Longshot's post on the night JEANS got lynched so bad? Am I tone deaf?
"Quite the predicament." - factual statement; we were in a predicament
"I'm not sure if I trust Jeans here. Doc is a big role to call and we have no evidence cuz day 1." - given the circumstances I think that it was reasonable to not completely trust JEANS
"Way I see it because he has called doc he probably wont make it past this night or tomorrow night anyways as he will be targeted by at least 1 mafia group (if both and reading how his powers work then he will be fully dead anyways)." - also correct; I know WIFOM is a thing but the risk/reward for mafia was heavily in favour of killing JEANS (you're either killing the town doctor or a rival mafioso and that's worth the "risk" of shooting the same player as the rival faction) so it WAS extremely likely that JEANS would be nightkilled quickly if not lynched (looking back this lynch choice just looks worse and worse UGH I'm so sorry JEANS).
"So its a question of whether we don't lynch and he will be dead soon. Or lynch a man calling doc." - accurate summary of the situation.
* * *
Looking through posts over the last couple of days it seems that people are relatively undecided on Windkeeper. If you read my large post earlier in the day on the topic, what did you agree / disagree with?
And also still looking through these posts it seems that uhh everyone that's bothered to share an opinion seems suspicious of Aerodrome? Today's lynch?
04/04/2019 00:51:52
So who isn't going away for Wollongong?
Bijou, Aerodrome, dean, JonCheee, Maribro, ThatLaggyPerson, Blaze, Boozer, Windkeeper0. May as well focus on these players for now.
JonCheee said:Who is "most people", Jon? Because I think at the time of this post it was only Extra and Maribro? And what in particular did you agree with the most?
for ltlongshot, most people have already described what i find suss about his play, not really sure how much i can add to this.
OK about Longshot. I think I need a little help, can someone help walk Uncle Dean through what made Longshot's post on the night JEANS got lynched so bad? Am I tone deaf?
"Quite the predicament." - factual statement; we were in a predicament
"I'm not sure if I trust Jeans here. Doc is a big role to call and we have no evidence cuz day 1." - given the circumstances I think that it was reasonable to not completely trust JEANS
"Way I see it because he has called doc he probably wont make it past this night or tomorrow night anyways as he will be targeted by at least 1 mafia group (if both and reading how his powers work then he will be fully dead anyways)." - also correct; I know WIFOM is a thing but the risk/reward for mafia was heavily in favour of killing JEANS (you're either killing the town doctor or a rival mafioso and that's worth the "risk" of shooting the same player as the rival faction) so it WAS extremely likely that JEANS would be nightkilled quickly if not lynched (looking back this lynch choice just looks worse and worse UGH I'm so sorry JEANS).
"So its a question of whether we don't lynch and he will be dead soon. Or lynch a man calling doc." - accurate summary of the situation.
* * *
Looking through posts over the last couple of days it seems that people are relatively undecided on Windkeeper. If you read my large post earlier in the day on the topic, what did you agree / disagree with?
And also still looking through these posts it seems that uhh everyone that's bothered to share an opinion seems suspicious of Aerodrome? Today's lynch?
04/04/2019 00:51:52
@aero why does Bijou not being on the jeans train put him as +town?
Also how am I playing strange? I haven't even played game here yet lmao.
@blaze just because you talk a lot doesn't mean you're saying anything.
Following this and Maribro sentiments I'm going to throw my vote on Boozer. I would like to hear thoughts on d1
Vote boozer
04/04/2019 01:13:41
Also how am I playing strange? I haven't even played game here yet lmao.
@blaze just because you talk a lot doesn't mean you're saying anything.
Following this and Maribro sentiments I'm going to throw my vote on Boozer. I would like to hear thoughts on d1
Vote boozer
04/04/2019 01:13:41
Hello im not getting errors rn wowow
Lynching aero would be funny. He always plays basically the same and everyone always has scum reads on him.
And then he always flips town lol. THIS time maybe different ??
Im inclined to agree with dean that i dont particularly think that lt outlining the jeans situation as he did is very scummy. Maybe marioboro trying to put heat on someone not on his own team ??
Can i vote for ben gold anyway
04/04/2019 01:18:25
Lynching aero would be funny. He always plays basically the same and everyone always has scum reads on him.
And then he always flips town lol. THIS time maybe different ??
Im inclined to agree with dean that i dont particularly think that lt outlining the jeans situation as he did is very scummy. Maybe marioboro trying to put heat on someone not on his own team ??
Can i vote for ben gold anyway
04/04/2019 01:18:25
No one's really given a good reason to be suspicious of me btw. There's very little reason to lynch me anyway since I always get night killed like day 2 or 3 lol.
@Blaze lurking is anti-town behavior. You weren't lynched because your posted a lot, you were lynched because your defense was garbage.
04/04/2019 01:41:56
@Blaze lurking is anti-town behavior. You weren't lynched because your posted a lot, you were lynched because your defense was garbage.
04/04/2019 01:41:56
Blaze said:Yes, that's OK. Who do you agree with the most and why do you agree with them?
most of my opinions are biased at this point based on what other people have said, and id just be repeating what othere have said.
Blaze said:By whom? No one seems to have said that in this thread.
And when i tried to make a big contribution i was kinda told it was bad lmao.
Blaze said:You said that you thought I was suspicious on Day 1. What's made you change your mind?
everyone looks really neutral to me.
Windkeeper0 said:You seem to be busy a lot. What's a day in the life of Windkeeper0 like?
I had a lot going on during the start of the game so I wasn't on as much as I would have liked.
I think that the rest of your post is reasonable. I still don't like it that your posts have either been you getting involved in a townie lynch or saying "I'm busy" a lot but I guess that coincidences can happen. Now that JEANS is dead did you have anything else to add about the game situation?
04/04/2019 02:18:36
Boozer said:Now that I think about it, Boozer has never been mafia in any of the games he's played, maybe this time will be different!
Hello im not getting errors rn wowow
Lynching aero would be funny. He always plays basically the same and everyone always has scum reads on him.
And then he always flips town lol. THIS time maybe different ??
Im inclined to agree with dean that i dont particularly think that lt outlining the jeans situation as he did is very scummy. Maybe marioboro trying to put heat on someone not on his own team ??
Can i vote for ben gold anyway
Vote: Boozer
04/04/2019 02:28:07
@dean i think it was bijou, he didnt exactly say it was bad but i probs took it that way, quotings bad on phone so will do later
04/04/2019 02:34:19
04/04/2019 02:34:19
Ive never seen you be mafia either aero !
04/04/2019 04:00:03
04/04/2019 04:00:03
ah sorry dean, by "most people" i meant most of the people who have given their opinion on ltlongshot.
in regards to maribros call out, i agree with the way he worded his statement within that time was rather suss. you can say factual things and still be maf, like ghost saying that jeans wouldnt really want to claim doc.
in regards to extra's, the "its ok if you think i'm maf" isnt a great showing. if ltlongshot rebuttaled any of this i must have missed it.
really not liking how laggy is going in this situation. is he just ignoring the game or something?
also is aero saying the longer he lives the more likely he's maf?
04/04/2019 05:23:49
in regards to maribros call out, i agree with the way he worded his statement within that time was rather suss. you can say factual things and still be maf, like ghost saying that jeans wouldnt really want to claim doc.
in regards to extra's, the "its ok if you think i'm maf" isnt a great showing. if ltlongshot rebuttaled any of this i must have missed it.
really not liking how laggy is going in this situation. is he just ignoring the game or something?
also is aero saying the longer he lives the more likely he's maf?
04/04/2019 05:23:49
Aerodrome said:I feel like I raised some solid points at the bottom of Page 16.
No one's really given a good reason to be suspicious of me btw.
At the very least, your response of "yeah my posts dont look too good LOL. i legitimately thought he was mafia though plesse undertsand" didn't really help to change my opinion.
Aerodrome said:Strange mentality.
There's very little reason to lynch me anyway since I always get night killed like day 2 or 3 lol.
If mafia thinks that a player is a reasonable chance to get lynched at some stage then they won't waste their nightkill on them.
If a player could potentially have a mafia power role then we want them dead sooner rather than giving them more opportunities to use their power.
And considering that you're in a game with Windkeeper0, Maribro, Extra, Bijou and an Innocent Child still alive you're no guarantee to be a high-priority night kill target.
IF the town thinks that YOU are the most likely player to be mafia then of course they should lynch you! The entire goal of the game for townies is to lynch the dudes that we think are mafia!
(Which you seemed to forget in your "reads post", where you were "willing to bet" that Blaze was mafia, were less sure on asa but still preferred lynching asa?)
UNVOTE for now.
04/04/2019 05:30:42