my thoughts
not convinced that jeans is scum just yet but also dont buy that him asking for asa to get modkilled was a 'joke'. theres some insincerity in his posts but also i get the feeling that if it happened he wouldn't be too sad about it. i think his reasoning for voting ghost was pretty bad.
feels like once again no one really wants to challenge dean but for what it's worth i think he is playing a little bit more pro town than in the ssbu mafia. i get a very no-nonsense feel from him. having said that, in this game each mafia side can play 'pro-town' by scumhunting the other side so it's a bit weird. i think it doesn't really matter on day 1, but something to keep in mind for the future.
blaze i reckon right now is poster child for 'clueless townie'. dont feel like hes scum at all
im not sure what to think of bijou but i think hes playing pretty similarly to the ssbu game. been very active and open which i think is a good sign, and responded to pressure reasonably. hes defs a smart player though so im keeping my eye on him and dean.
@ moderators: whats the rules for the mafia chats? are they restricted to only night talk like in ssbu mafia? idk if its usually shared publicly or whatever.
im gonna vote for boozer because hes the only person who's been more quiet than me recently!! ive had a busy few days (was out basically all day sunday/monday sorry) but i dont want invisi to yell at me more so ill try to step it up.
vote: boozer
03/19/2019 13:22:56
Bijou said:
I still feel it's really really nitpicking but I feel like your "wtf is a dharkon" post is an indicator that you (or someone on your team) might be that character. You didn't mention anything about galeem.
every character but whoever dharkon is is a spirit or character, galeem was shown in the prerelease stuff. I looked it up since because whatever and it's some eyeball monsters. amazing.
asa said:
What are your thoughts on bijou?
Given that he's probably been the most vocal in the speculation about the setup
Do you agree with the speculation? 4-4-8? 3-3-10?
thoughts on bijou relating to what exaclty? the speculation shit, why are you asking ME this.
if i must express then
i think he's townnnnnn cause he's being nice to me.
:)
being nice to someone with 5(6) votes on them is not a scum play. Also since it's a double mafia game me the mafia would be even less likely defending of people.
As a mafia, personally, I appear town through agreeing with town, defending town people can do this and I did it a bunch last game as mafia. but in a double mafia setup, you dont know the person you're defending is town or not.. then by chance they're in the other mafia you look like a mafia. So yeah, since I know im town, and bijou is the only one defending me, Im very confident he's town.
hopefully you guys understand what im trying to say I feel i couldve explained it better.
dean said:
Anyway I actually think set-up speculation on day 1 is rubbish and not helpful and I'm already guilty of contributing to it too much so should probably leave it there; we're nearly three days and several dozen posts into the game so there should be something else to chat about.
i agree with this. im not good at that number ratio zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz garbage , my speculation on it adds nothing.
((.what amazing information was gained from this great pressure asa. im clearly the E(xist) tier and you're the SSS tier that can break down day 1 posts while being the mod and knowing what faction they are already on.
[citation needed but somebody said something about his day 1 post explanations or someshit in one of the channels and it works better in my post if this is what happened'))
(this is from an old draft where I replied with like 2 words to asa but I want to leave it in, BUT just cause im saying this in direct response to him doesnt mean he's GOOD, and doesn't mean he's doing ANYTHING, i was gonna go off about this anyways)
JonCheee said:
my current thoughts on people:
jeans: wasnt super impressed with his current defense, and his reasoning for attacking ghost is odd, and i especially dont like his 2nd point about aero's voting habits. i think he's scum but he could also be dumb.
yea ok most of day 1 is people throwing votes around for no reason I throw some possibilities out there (that yeah are probably wrong sue me). What do you want from me. sorry for using my vote our strongest weapon i guess.
Ghostbone said:
the "Modkill this guy" into "Actually I was just kidding" option select if they don't get modkilled isn't really a compelling defense to me.
noone has got modkilled in a ausmsash mafia game occurrence, correct me if im wrong as i dont follow every game but ive never experienced it happening. and i surely doubt the deciding factor for a mod to finally modkill someone is 1 player asking and he also clearly just doesnt like him. the whole 'option select' would never work because noone would be modkilled just cause 1 person asked. Did you not see me the last 2 games, even bijou who's known as a strong player is saying wow jeans sure did play fucking amazing last games and I love him. (more or less, ty bijou ). So yeah I would defs go from that to the amazing play this is modkill option select.
saying i Only reason someone has to be modkilled is if they break the rules, but im pretty sure in past games many a rule has been broken and noone has really cared because these mafia games are (unless ive followed the tone wrong for 3 years) are casual so the mods wont be strict and modkill someone 2 minutes into day 1 for making a terrible shitpost for the sake of the game. if the mods WERE strict they wouldve just kille him on the spot and not let the influence of whoever wants him modkilled control the pace of the game. (like its doing rn you could argue eh my bad lol)
also just to back up my asa hate boner lol blaze and bijou agree with me he's a dick yea there u go.
god this post is a fucking mess
03/19/2019 14:16:30
I just woke up in the middle of the night and realised I hadn't posted I thought I would ch
03/19/2019 16:11:20
03/19/2019 16:11:20
Ahhh I was dead all day soz
This jeans feud is wild
I know for a fact that jeans doesn't have a switch of his own (it's his brothers) and he very rarely gets to play it so he definitely hasn't finished WoL (idk where he'd be up to at all tho) so I'm not going to hold that against him
Idk his defences seem pretty typical of him so idk what to say about that
Like I don't necessarily think he's Mafia but I also don't think he's town like idk
@extra: it's never disclosed if they have night talk or not, or at least it wasn't in ultimate Mafia or last Mafia game (we didn't have night talk last game btw idk if y'all knew :p)
Oh yeah I just remembered Jeans voted ghost and it was like just kinda like ??? k idk what weird Oh sup windkeeper we both suck at sleeping I see
03/19/2019 16:17:42
This jeans feud is wild
I know for a fact that jeans doesn't have a switch of his own (it's his brothers) and he very rarely gets to play it so he definitely hasn't finished WoL (idk where he'd be up to at all tho) so I'm not going to hold that against him
Idk his defences seem pretty typical of him so idk what to say about that
Like I don't necessarily think he's Mafia but I also don't think he's town like idk
@extra: it's never disclosed if they have night talk or not, or at least it wasn't in ultimate Mafia or last Mafia game (we didn't have night talk last game btw idk if y'all knew :p)
Oh yeah I just remembered Jeans voted ghost and it was like just kinda like ??? k idk what weird Oh sup windkeeper we both suck at sleeping I see
03/19/2019 16:17:42
check in now while I'm up I'll go into more detail later but for now I'll unvote since we still have quite a bit of time to use and I have a couple of things I want to go over after we've finished with the topic. Also im a bit more on the fence about Jeans right now but I'll go over that tomorrow.
vote:unvote That post ended up such a mess wow.
03/19/2019 16:19:25
vote:unvote That post ended up such a mess wow.
03/19/2019 16:19:25
Extra said:
@ moderators: whats the rules for the mafia chats? are they restricted to only night talk like in ssbu mafia? idk if its usually shared publicly or whatever.
I won't be publicly disclosing this information, sorry.
03/19/2019 22:54:42
Jeans said:
bijou is the only one defending me, Im very confident he's town.
What gives you the impression that Bijou is defending you?
03/19/2019 23:11:03
Morning nerds.
a) Extra had already pointed it out
b) I was intending to push a FoS onto BattleDolphin in a separate post (who I will be referring to as Lachlan from this point in the game because BattleDolphin is an atrocious tag) but I cooled on the idea until more water had passed under the bridge.
What about Windkeeper's post struck your attention, William? What distinguished this post from the other 50 or so that had already been posted? Come now, hold my hand and guide me through this.
Anyway...
If we wanted to lynch based off doing strange things then I think Lachlan's "Why is windkeeper so good at looking like a townie lmaooo" is the strangest thing posted in this thread so far.
But I was thinking before last night about putting FoS onto Windkeeper because:
a) I thought he was acting a little weirdly in his previous posts (with a whopping sample size of three, admittedly)
b) As a bonus, both Lachlan and Maribro have had weird interactions with him so learning his flip might have helped us understand the underlying relationships a little better.
But now I'm starting to doubt myself. Anyway he said in his last post he has some things to go into so I'm interested to hear about those. Judging by his posting habits I'm not sure how long I'll be waiting though.
03/19/2019 23:42:59
asa said:What are YOUR thoughts on Bijou, Mr. sit-in-a-corner-and-throw-votes-around?
What are your thoughts on bijou?
Maribro said:There were two reasons for that:
I just thought it was a good post, BD agreed with me and you didn't pull him up…
a) Extra had already pointed it out
b) I was intending to push a FoS onto BattleDolphin in a separate post (who I will be referring to as Lachlan from this point in the game because BattleDolphin is an atrocious tag) but I cooled on the idea until more water had passed under the bridge.
What about Windkeeper's post struck your attention, William? What distinguished this post from the other 50 or so that had already been posted? Come now, hold my hand and guide me through this.
Extra said:Top player privilege. You might get to experience it one day.
feels like once again no one really wants to challenge dean
Anyway...
If we wanted to lynch based off doing strange things then I think Lachlan's "Why is windkeeper so good at looking like a townie lmaooo" is the strangest thing posted in this thread so far.
But I was thinking before last night about putting FoS onto Windkeeper because:
a) I thought he was acting a little weirdly in his previous posts (with a whopping sample size of three, admittedly)
b) As a bonus, both Lachlan and Maribro have had weird interactions with him so learning his flip might have helped us understand the underlying relationships a little better.
But now I'm starting to doubt myself. Anyway he said in his last post he has some things to go into so I'm interested to hear about those. Judging by his posting habits I'm not sure how long I'll be waiting though.
03/19/2019 23:42:59
sorry to go off on a tangent,, but id like to hear more from Mr L, I feel like from what i've heard and can infer hes notorious for signing up and not playing, and then he accuses me of not contributing.
Vote: Mr L
03/20/2019 00:39:31
Vote: Mr L
03/20/2019 00:39:31
I'd rather lynch BattleDolphin than Windkeeper.
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/20/2019 02:02:44
Vote: BattleDolphin
03/20/2019 02:02:44
dean said:
Morning nerds.
asa said:What are YOUR thoughts on Bijou, Mr. sit-in-a-corner-and-throw-votes-around?
What are your thoughts on bijou?
Maribro said:There were two reasons for that:
I just thought it was a good post, BD agreed with me and you didn't pull him up…
a) Extra had already pointed it out
b) I was intending to push a FoS onto BattleDolphin in a separate post (who I will be referring to as Lachlan from this point in the game because BattleDolphin is an atrocious tag) but I cooled on the idea until more water had passed under the bridge.
What about Windkeeper's post struck your attention, William? What distinguished this post from the other 50 or so that had already been posted? Come now, hold my hand and guide me through this.
What really caught my eye about this post was something aero said about windkeeper last game. Something along the lines of “mafia don’t give out information for free”. This post just struck me as too informative too early on to be from a scummy scum mcscum.
I’m still very much learning my way around this game and using things others have said about previous games is helping me navigate this one.
Also do you think my tag is atrocious lmao, why you hitting me with the “William”?!
dean said:
Anyway...
If we wanted to lynch based off doing strange things then I think Lachlan's "Why is windkeeper so good at looking like a townie lmaooo" is the strangest thing posted in this thread so far.
But I was thinking before last night about putting FoS onto Windkeeper because:
a) I thought he was acting a little weirdly in his previous posts (with a whopping sample size of three, admittedly)
b) As a bonus, both Lachlan and Maribro have had weird interactions with him so learning his flip might have helped us understand the underlying relationships a little better.
But now I'm starting to doubt myself. Anyway he said in his last post he has some things to go into so I'm interested to hear about those. Judging by his posting habits I'm not sure how long I'll be waiting though.
What do you think we’ll learn depending on his different flip options?
Personally I don’t want to lynch windkeeper atm, besides dean, he’s probably my most likely vote for townie. May as we’ll share my thoughts on that anyways
Town lean: windkeeper, dean, blaze
Neutral: everyone else
Scum lean: aero, JEANS, asa, JonCheee
03/20/2019 03:18:41
asa said:
Jeans said:
bijou is the only one defending me, Im very confident he's town.
What gives you the impression that Bijou is defending you?
I wouldn't go as far to say I was defending him either btw lol. Was more just encouraging him to defend himself which I think he did much better the second time around.
Regarding the Windkeeper direction I think BD's "how is Windkeeper so town lmaooo" could potentially be BD trying to make his mafia team look good. It's kinda along the same level as us accusing Jeans for his 'wtf dharkon' post.
I don't feel like BD would make such a dumb play if he's actually teamed with him though. Still, I'd like to hear his explaination regarding it.
Vote: Battledolphin
Pls respond : )
03/20/2019 04:18:01
dean said:evidence.zip
What are YOUR thoughts on Bijou, Mr. sit-in-a-corner-and-throw-votes-around?
03/20/2019 04:29:43
is asa a jester
03/20/2019 04:33:19
03/20/2019 04:33:19
Aerodrome said:I realise this is probably a joke comment, but I should mention that I did previously confirm that this game contains no independent players, because it seems most of you missed that announcement.
is asa a jester
03/20/2019 04:48:55
WARNING - OVERSIZE DO NOT OVERTAKE TURNING VEHICLE
First thing to pique my notice. WIth an unusual setup, there's bound to be a bit of speculation.
What I expect a normal response to setup speculation to look like
The next big thing that interests me:
What's so relevant about only 1 mafia faction being able to win? Just because there are 2 mafia factions doesn't mean that town-mafia balance goes out the window.
I bring this up because to me, this shows a slightly different mentality which completely ignores the town now that it's about the 2 mafia factions (what do I have to do to win? Eliminate the other faction. Town is just npc)
This is also the second time the potential of 4 mafia teams has been mentioned.
The way it's ordered, bringing up past 3-3 setup, but then suggesting the potential of 4-4 feels like he's leaning towards that. Maybe he has extra information?
I've never played multi-mafia game before so I had a look at setups of games of similar size
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Two-Fold_JK9%2B%2B
18 players 3-3-12
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Kill_All_Townies
17 3-3-11
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Mafia_X
10 2-2-6
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Twofold_Mafia
12 2-2-8
Looking at these setups, I would expect somewhere between 2-3 mafia, leaning towards 3 or really strong 2s(homebrew?) because it seems mafia need some help on aus smash
So the very idea of 4-4 mafia teams is alarming to me. I don't see in what world is this balanced with 50% anti-town.
The sane response to this suggestion.
Aero votes bijou here. Likely for these reasons.
I don't see this as a random vote at all given this timing.
My vote actually didn't have anything to do with this post of aero's,
it just happened to occur at an unfortunate timing before I refreshed the page.
Again, I feel like there's just something off about this mentality. As town, it's still Town vs Mafia+Mafia.
Just because the mafia factions are against each other doesn't make the town more powerful.
This is the point where "what the fuck is a dharkon" happens
lmao
Sorta like how the only reason we're even worrying about the setup is because you let it slip that we should be cautious about some information that we shouldn't know?
PART 2 - ETA TBD
EDIT - THE GODS HAVE BEEN FORGIVING AND ALLOWED ME TO FIX MY FORMATTING!
03/20/2019 07:56:54
Jonchee - page 2
wow its started woohoo. 2 mafia factions probably means lots of mafia right?
assuming 3-4 per faction or is that too big of an assumption cos that would be 6-8 mafia in a 16 person game.
thats almost/is half the game
First thing to pique my notice. WIth an unusual setup, there's bound to be a bit of speculation.
Windkeeper - page 3
Hello, since this game has 2 mafia groups and the only other game I can remember doing that on this site is the smashbox one it probably has a similar setup.
It had 3 mafia members on each side and a similar size so I assume it would be the same in this game.
What I expect a normal response to setup speculation to look like
Battledolphin - page 3
Also 2 people for each faction seems too small so I imagine it's 3v3v10
The next big thing that interests me:
Bijou - Page 3
So people are thinking the setup is probably 3-3-10 based on the last game with two factions?
The difference in this game is only one mafia faction can win so potentially it could even be 4-4-8?
For a mafia faction to win they would need to eliminate everybody in the other faction first and after that have more/ the same members as town.
So compared to the last game the different rules would actually allow the mods to setup the game with completely half anti town and half town if they wanted to.
What's so relevant about only 1 mafia faction being able to win? Just because there are 2 mafia factions doesn't mean that town-mafia balance goes out the window.
I bring this up because to me, this shows a slightly different mentality which completely ignores the town now that it's about the 2 mafia factions (what do I have to do to win? Eliminate the other faction. Town is just npc)
This is also the second time the potential of 4 mafia teams has been mentioned.
The way it's ordered, bringing up past 3-3 setup, but then suggesting the potential of 4-4 feels like he's leaning towards that. Maybe he has extra information?
I've never played multi-mafia game before so I had a look at setups of games of similar size
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Two-Fold_JK9%2B%2B
18 players 3-3-12
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Kill_All_Townies
17 3-3-11
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Mafia_X
10 2-2-6
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Twofold_Mafia
12 2-2-8
Looking at these setups, I would expect somewhere between 2-3 mafia, leaning towards 3 or really strong 2s(homebrew?) because it seems mafia need some help on aus smash
So the very idea of 4-4 mafia teams is alarming to me. I don't see in what world is this balanced with 50% anti-town.
Dean - Page 3
Four mafiosi in each faction would be ludicrous. I feel like lynching the nerds that suggested it. Are you guys trying to mislead town?
The sane response to this suggestion.
Aero votes bijou here. Likely for these reasons.
I don't see this as a random vote at all given this timing.
Aerodrome said:
Extra said:
i actually would like to hear why aero voted bijou.
No reason in particular
asa said:
Yeah I agree with Aero
Vote Bijou
My vote actually didn't have anything to do with this post of aero's,
it just happened to occur at an unfortunate timing before I refreshed the page.
Bijou - Page 5
Yeah that might be true in a normal game but this game effectively has three teams vs each other so you can't apply that in this case.
You're treating it as town vs anti town, but in reality this game is A vs B vs C.
Again, I feel like there's just something off about this mentality. As town, it's still Town vs Mafia+Mafia.
Just because the mafia factions are against each other doesn't make the town more powerful.
This is the point where "what the fuck is a dharkon" happens
Bijou - Page 6
As a super low key play too if I'm actually right about the setup then the only people that know for sure how many mafia there are
(ie. the anti town players) would believe I'm on the other mafia faction and start voting for me or calling me out.
To be honest the main reason for discussing game set up at all is to get the mafia players who know some of the setup
(ie. the number of anti town) to slip up and reveal information they shouldn't know.
lmao
Sorta like how the only reason we're even worrying about the setup is because you let it slip that we should be cautious about some information that we shouldn't know?
PART 2 - ETA TBD
EDIT - THE GODS HAVE BEEN FORGIVING AND ALLOWED ME TO FIX MY FORMATTING!
03/20/2019 07:56:54
Town is actually more powerful in a town vs maf vs maf setup because mafia have to kill each other too.
A 10v3v3 game is obviously a lot easier than a 10v6 game.
03/20/2019 09:54:51
A 10v3v3 game is obviously a lot easier than a 10v6 game.
03/20/2019 09:54:51
The way it's ordered, bringing up past 3-3 setup, but then suggesting the potential of 4-4 feels like he's leaning towards that. Maybe he has extra information?
So the very idea of 4-4 mafia teams is alarming to me. I don't see in what world is this balanced with 50% anti-town.
You spend a considerable amount of time telling me that a 4-4-8 game isn't going to happen, yet now you're implying I have extra information (about the game potentially being 4-4-8).
Make up your mind, you can't have it both ways. Which is it?
My vote actually didn't have anything to do with this post of aero's
it just happened to occur at an unfortunate timing before I refreshed the page.
The only thing Aero did prior to posting was vote me and say nothing. So essentially you were agreeing with that?
I know above this you mentioned he probably voted me for certain reasons, but you don't know what he's thinking for sure. Nobody knows for certain whatever Aero is thinking.
You seem pretty certain you know what he's thinking, perhaps you're in a team together?
Again, I feel like there's just something off about this mentality. As town, it's still Town vs Mafia+Mafia.
Just because the mafia factions are against each other doesn't make the town more powerful.
No, you're just wrong. It's town vs mafia vs mafia. There are three independent teams this game.
Only one of these teams can win, therefore everyone is against everyone else.
Sorta like how the only reason we're even worrying about the setup is because you let it slip that we should be cautious about some information that we shouldn't know?
It's hardly letting it slip, anyone who was going to discuss it would have already done by that point.
A lot of people seemed confused as to why we should discuss it at all. So I revealed why.
And hey look it's working, look at the novel you wrote in response to it.
I await part two with baited breath.
Ghostbone said:
Town is actually more powerful in a town vs maf vs maf setup because mafia have to kill each other too.
A 10v3v3 game is obviously a lot easier than a 10v6 game.
Yeah, this. Ghost articulated it better than me.
03/20/2019 10:32:16
vote:asa
christ.
03/20/2019 12:34:19
christ.
03/20/2019 12:34:19
Not much to contribute, but I think 3 mafia on each team makes sense. I’d be fine with either asa or jeans for a day 1 lynch
03/20/2019 21:40:30
03/20/2019 21:40:30
What's an FoS lmao
Lmao there is NO way I'd be calling my Mafia team good ever if I was on it, especially after last game
Ngl I definitely thought the Windkeeper post I was referring to was directly before my post but I think Maribro quoting it a few times messed with my brain lmao
But if you look at the Windkeeper post I was referring to (will post after this, on mobile), it's clearly a very good post to open the game with (it was his first post)
This is the post
03/21/2019 04:46:31
Bijou said:
Regarding the Windkeeper direction I think BD's "how is Windkeeper so town lmaooo" could potentially be BD trying to make his mafia team look good. It's kinda along the same level as us accusing Jeans for his 'wtf dharkon' post.
I don't feel like BD would make such a dumb play if he's actually teamed with him though. Still, I'd like to hear his explaination regarding it.
Lmao there is NO way I'd be calling my Mafia team good ever if I was on it, especially after last game
Ngl I definitely thought the Windkeeper post I was referring to was directly before my post but I think Maribro quoting it a few times messed with my brain lmao
But if you look at the Windkeeper post I was referring to (will post after this, on mobile), it's clearly a very good post to open the game with (it was his first post)
Windkeeper0 said:
Hello, since this game has 2 mafia groups and the only other game I can remember doing that on this site is the smashbox one it probably has a similar setup. It had 3 mafia members on each side and a similar size so I assume it would be the same in this game.
Now that that's out of the way, I don't really know what to do with the current situation. Invisi said earlier that there were no independent roles and from what JEANS said he claimed a ridiculous role so he was clearly joking. What he said doesn't seem particularly scummy from what JEANS stated and he wasn't modkilled so I guess we continue on?
We can't just let it kill the discussion on the first day so we should either find another topic and keep our eye on asa or pressure him to see if he messes up again. The topic doesn't seem very productive since it's just people being shocked but if someone knows how to expand it into a meaningful discussion, it would be good to hear.
This is the post
03/21/2019 04:46:31
do they not have google in queensland or something
03/21/2019 05:15:58
03/21/2019 05:15:58
Yeah okay I'm good with that reply BD.
Vote: unvote
03/21/2019 05:32:50
Vote: unvote
03/21/2019 05:32:50
Maribro said:OK not that much in hindsight. Even if he flipped mafia I don't think that you'd suck up to him this obviously / be galaxybrain enough for the double bluff if you were scum.
What do you think we’ll learn depending on his different flip options?
Maribro said:
Personally I don’t want to lynch windkeeper atm, besides dean, he’s probably my most likely vote for townie. May as we’ll share my thoughts on that anyways
Town lean: windkeeper, dean, blaze
Neutral: everyone else
Scum lean: aero, JEANS, asa, JonCheee
This is an interesting flip in mentality from your previous game:
Maribro said:
Windkeeper0 - Always see him as a danger due to never losing a game (I don't think??) so I'm cautious. Hasn't done anything suss yet but I have a hard time trusting him because of his gigantic power level.
Maribro said:
Windkeeper0 - Much like MrL, has acted in a very townie fashion. I like his posts and I think they come from a good place. I just find it hard to trust such a strong and versatile player.
You've found it hard to trust him in the past but you'd town-lean him this game because he suggested that the 20-man Smashbox game and this current 16-man game would have a similar set-up. I see.
03/21/2019 05:33:56
With JEANS defence I don't know about him saying he was joking about mod-killing asa and voting for ghost seemed a bit out of place but I can kind of see why you dislike asa better now. I also think the 'what's that' post might be a bit too nitpicky by itself to lynch him. I'm still not sure he's town but I think we have enough on him to warrant a lynch unless we don't find someone else.
To be fair that post was made at 3 in the morning, while I was half asleep and I was rushing it more than I normally would.
i agree that is it was weird that they openly responded so positively so early but usually the mafia wants to distance themselves and with there being two factions, I feel like that sentiment would be stronger in this game. I could see something like this happening later on when there is more than 1 post but when everyone is looking for even a minor slip up on day 1 it doesn't seem like a good strategy.
I have to go for now but I'll try to go over everything else later tonight. I'll try to be more active so things don't snowball quite this much.
This was supposed to be don't think. I'm still not able to get a full post in yet but I should still be able to later.
03/21/2019 09:35:47
dean said:
But I was thinking before last night about putting FoS onto Windkeeper because:
a) I thought he was acting a little weirdly in his previous posts (with a whopping sample size of three, admittedly)
To be fair that post was made at 3 in the morning, while I was half asleep and I was rushing it more than I normally would.
dean said:
b) As a bonus, both Lachlan and Maribro have had weird interactions with him so learning his flip might have helped us understand the underlying relationships a little better.
i agree that is it was weird that they openly responded so positively so early but usually the mafia wants to distance themselves and with there being two factions, I feel like that sentiment would be stronger in this game. I could see something like this happening later on when there is more than 1 post but when everyone is looking for even a minor slip up on day 1 it doesn't seem like a good strategy.
I have to go for now but I'll try to go over everything else later tonight. I'll try to be more active so things don't snowball quite this much.
Windkeeper0 said:
I think we have enough on him to warrant a lynch unless we don't find someone else.
This was supposed to be don't think. I'm still not able to get a full post in yet but I should still be able to later.
03/21/2019 09:35:47